that saftey orange i think is a little bright compared to the burnt orange your car was originally, i know the color, my dad's bug was that color originally, my bug was the brighter later orange, the paint i used was really close to the original color of my car, the color of your car if it is the darker red color is not the same orange of my car.

my bug (74) was a arizona car, and completely rust free. but looking at your pic, you really should pull that back window, and cut/weld in new metal.