The carpets they are making look great now. When "they" ship it rolled up in the 12"X12"x48" boxes, it loses it's shape. It is hard to get a proper fit and the carpet NEVER gets back it's original form. The adhesive material is similar to a hot glue substance. Unless you put it back into it's original mold, reheat and form press it, the carpet will try and go back to the last shape it was conformed to. If a bumpy loose fit doesn't bother you, then I say go with the rolled stuff!