Current situation. I saved the original tail light lenses with sanding/polishing.

The reproduction bezels have the problems that everyone says/they don't fit exactly right.
But they do look like they belong there, and I found them at a discount so I can't complain much.

The GTX emblem is the one that's been on the car as long as I've owned it, and might be original... it's not perfect but fine for now. The plymouth emblem is from a swap meet.
I spent some time cleaning and refinishing those. Pretty easy project to paint and solvent wipe the face.