I don't have a dog in this fight. I just want to state the facts as I found. I had inquired about ordering a set of this carpet. I was told it would be a while before any would be available. The salesman took my name and number. A few months later I received a call that orders were being taken. I sent in patch of my old carpet for color matching, the salesman returned my call saying they had an exact match. OK, order was placed and about a month later I had my carpet. Yes, the fit was beautiful. I didn't follow up and ask for an exchange. I know these interiors fade and discolor. So it is on me that I didn't contact ECS. I appreciate the offer of a replacement. But, obviously some of the responsibility is on me.