There is no doubt that the repop noses are very nice looking. I don't have anything bad to say about them.

In the case where Jack McGaughey has your car on site and can personally fit his nose to it, I am sure you could get a better fit than factory. If Jack or Gean ships you a nose, I don't know that there is any guarantee it will or won't fit better than a factory piece.

A repro nose will definitely cost less. If cost is a concern, I don't see anything wrong going repro. That said, the real deal is still the real deal. Some people will not want a reproduction piece of sheet metal on their car if a factory part is available.