I've had MetLife for years on the Drivers - they were easy to deal with on claims when I ran collision shops, and had inexpensive rates - and wasn't happy that Farmers bought them.
(Farmers was horrible on auto claims in Spokane, Nationwide almost as bad, Safeco depended on who I dealt with but mostly bad.)
Hasn't been a problem yet, but will shop around when my Independent Agent gets free of the non-compete clause Farmers made her sign.
Home policy is American Modern.
Around here, Farm Bureau has a good rep and I never had problems with them.