Well PayPal pretty much closed this dispute.
They yesterday issued a finding of "Deny" regarding buyers claim.

Strange IMO, in Paypal's first contact with me they required a reply to contest the claim within 10 days, or they would rule in favor of the claim, then take 45 days to get here.

And I'm outside the UPS claim window for shipping damages by 10 days..

What they also did not mention in that first contact, my reply would be a "one and done", meaning I had effectively no avenue to followup with any rebuttal or more evidence if it became necessary. So a warning, if in a Paypal dispute, don't hold anything back.

My guess, the buyer reshipped the items to China and they got trashed, and he could not make any case otherwise, and dropped it.

I surprised, and glad. up

Last edited by jcc; 03/05/20 09:56 AM.
Reality check, that half the population is smarter then 50% of the people and it's a constantly contested fact.