What spine axles are you using?
I think all the early, pre 35 spline axles Dana 60, had the two piece side gears, I saw the first one piece side gears in a 1970 E body Dana 60.
I have also seen a original 23 spline Dana 60 in a early production (assemble in early Oct of 1969) V code 1970 Charger RT 4 speed car with 4.10 gears
Don't feel bad on this it is not the first time I've seen guys put the wrong axle in the wrong side in a race Dana 60
Order a rebuild kit from Cass at Dr. Diff to replace those bad clutches and drive plates, make sure the axle engagement is correct also