Originally Posted by INTMD8
A few more bits of info from engine builders-



From Darin Morgan (was at Reher-Morrison now I believe BES)

"A cast iron block with cast iron heads will make more power than any other combination.
A cast iron block with aluminum heads will make less power.
An aluminum block with aluminum heads will make even less power."



From Larry Meaux (pipemax creator)

"a back-to-back Dyno test on SBC
cast-iron Bowtie Block -vs- alum Block
everything exactly the same, just blocks were swapped
there was 30 HP difference at 600 rpm/sec

another back-to-back Big Block Chevy test = approx 40 HP

another back-to-back SS Hemi test on Cylinder Heads only
with cast-iron -vs- aluminum = 12 HP more w/cast-iron
same flow numbers + port vol CC's

i did another similar test with my own personal SBC dyno test engine
..on the small block Chevy, it was a solid 8+ HP gain with
cast-iron over aluminum head.

the above were actual Dyno tests,
for theoretical HP/TQ differences between alum -vs- iron Blocks
by using FlowBench CFM Numbers -vs- what HP the different
block materials made on the Dyno =>

the results were=> for the same Flow CFM numbers,
i have yet to see an aluminum block engine make
the same HP/TQ that the cast-iron Block engine makes.

so far in all my Data,
the cast-iron Block always 100.0 % PerCent of time
makes more HP/TQ than an aluminum block

since Heat=HP/TQ
i think most of it might have been lost
to aluminum block acting like one big Heat-Sink
and some of it to ring blowby cfm w/alum.










I don’t disagree with any of that. In fact, I whole heartedly agree that an aluminum block won’t make the power an iron one will. I know this from back to back testing and found it the same every time. I’ve never tested the same with heads, but Morgan and Meaux are two of the smartest, most experienced guys in the field, so I don’t doubt their results with head materiel changes.

What I’m not seeing is how this relates to detonation resistance. IMO it doesn’t, because the transient response time for detonation to occur is so fast the head materiel is of no consequence. I was running higher than orthodox pump gas compression ratios clear back in 1984. And never have I seen an aluminum headed engine take more compression (or an iron head taking less compression) before detonation sets in.


Just because you think it won't make it true. Horsepower is KING. To dispute this is stupid. C. Alston