Unless you're a glutton for punishment, sell your 8.75 and move on to a stronger rearend that will actually take some abuse. If you make decent power and the car isn't a featherweight, you will fill the bottom of the housing w/ teeth.
You CAN build a Dana for your car from a truck housing for a LOT less than what a new rear costs if you're willing to put forth the effort.
You will not go slower due to the weight of a Dana...that's been proven over and over, yet people refuse to accept it.
A 9" IS A BETTER OPTION, but do the math on it and see what you're willing to spend. You have to realize a good 9" won't use any factory parts other than maybe the rear housing (not the center section). That rear housing also needs a backbrace.