Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: dangina]
#1193488
04/04/12 12:22 AM
04/04/12 12:22 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 284 Louisiana
kzinge1
OP
enthusiast
|
OP
enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 284
Louisiana
|
Quote:
remember if you don't like it - you can always swap it out for a bigger/smaller bar later!
That's true. At least the bars aren't really that expensive. For now I am just going to leave it off altogether and see how my next round of mods turns out without it.
I am still undecided about the torsion bar size. It would be cheaper to go 1" from Just Suspension but if it's worth it to go to a bigger bar I will spring for bigger ones from FF. I just don't want something that's going to ride like a log truck. Hopefully the Bilstein shocks will allow me to run bigger bars comfortably.
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: kzinge1]
#1193489
04/04/12 09:35 AM
04/04/12 09:35 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 1,645 Phila. Pa.
Mattax
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 1,645
Phila. Pa.
|
Kzinge - Since the car has a lighter front, let's take this relationship a bit further. Reducing mass (weight) on one end of the car has the same effect as increasing spring rate. Also, street tires and particularly unpaved roads are better suited to softer spring. Let me give an example in the other direction.
My car was using 200 #/in t-bars and a 1.125 sway bar which were working reasonably well in autocross on A008 tires. After installing a set of R1 tires, traction increased but the car rolled much more. Stickyier tires needed more roll resistance (or less weight, lower cg and roll centers). But if we put the super stiff setup on loose surface or even a normal dirty road with street tires and it might skate instead of bite.
That said, to pinpoint exactly the right t-bar for any vehicle requires much more specific information. Shifting as little as 50 pounds from the front the rear can effect the balance when driving. Also, on a B-body, my recollection is that the t-bars are longer than an A-body. Therefore a 1.03" B-body spring is softer than a 1.03" A-body t-bar (about 200 #/in). I*think* you will be in the ball park with anything in the 1" range. Yes, it worth discussing with the venders. And the business about ride height has to do with hex offsets.
If you want to baseline your car, my suggestion is to start collecting information. When you get the XHDs, measure the rate and free arches. When you remove the SS springs, measure them too. Next time the opporunity comes, weigh the car and if you can weigh the front. When you do, note how much fuel and other material is in the car (100 lbs of tools?) and its best if you sit in it. There's a page on my website discussing neutral line and how I applied it to my car but that is probably a step more than most people want to do or than makes sense on street car.
Dangina - As far as just trying the rear sway bar, if you put the car into a tree or telephone pole sideways, you may not get a chance to just take it off. That's what Rick E, FrankenDuster and the rest of us are at pains to point out. You need to sneak up on the rear roll from the safe side, especially on a street car. Please read what Rick wrote about oversteer and speed in that other thread.
Last edited by Mattax; 04/04/12 09:41 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: vynn3]
#1193493
04/04/12 05:23 PM
04/04/12 05:23 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,388 Pikes Peak Country
TC@HP2
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,388
Pikes Peak Country
|
Like mattax said, there are a number of somewhat precise but actually kind of simple calculations that need to be known to fully dial in the needed spring rates a car need. It all starts with total weight and front/rear weight distribution. Without at least these two, everything else is just guesses. With just these two, you can at least dial it in to where you are not just in the ball park, but you're in the right section at the stadium. If you know your front/rear weight distribution, you can find the roll couple percentage required on the neuteral handling line. Once you know what roll couple you need, then you can find out what the required wheel rates need to be. Once you know that, then you can divide that rate into the available t-bars and s-bars to achieve balance. None of this is rocket science, it all is simple calculations actually, but if you don't have access to all the info to give you this information and know how to put it all together, then I guess it might just as well be rocket science. In simplest terms without doing any math, you could always look up the old Direct Connection Oval Track Kit Car specifications. These tables are all published in the associated mopar oval track book. They show a variety of t-bar, s-bar and leaf spring specifications in combinations that will put you within certain ranges of roll couple distribution. You'll still need to know weight and distribution, but it is better than guessing. IMO, the biggest issue with handling in classic mopars is the limited choice of front torsion bars. With only 5 choices in large rates ( maybe 7 if you find some of the out of production large sizes on ebay) you can only do so much with actual spring rates. Quote:
The weight distribution should be decent on my car, I have aluminum heads/intake, manual box, battery in the trunk and a fiberglass hood.
Assuming you have a 56-58% front weight bias, and that is being generous for a big block, even with the lightening you've done, you may need around 180-200# worth of rear spring to match the 1.03 torsion bars and 1.125 sway bar. So if swap out those SS springs for something considerably softer, you may be able to get away with a rear sway bar.
Quote:
I'm not looking for anyone to do all the thinking here, I was just looking for some direction. Is it a matter of calculating a spring rate increase of the torsion bars and then adding some additional leafs to the rear? Thanks for any help. Jeff
If your happy with the overall balance now, then yes, you can calculate the percentage of step up on your t-bars, leave your sway-bar in place, and step up the leafs a corresponding amount. However, I'm talking about the feel of balance front to rear, not whether it is a wallowing pig that rolls over for a belly scratch when you turn. If you change your front s-bar at the same time or add a rear s-bar, or it plows and slides too easily now, then the percentages have changed and that type of straight calcualtion won't work.
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: Mattax]
#1193496
04/04/12 09:34 PM
04/04/12 09:34 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 4,302 Nebraska
72Swinger
master
|
master
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 4,302
Nebraska
|
Someone needs to buy some A-body bars from Dick so we can speed up the need for him to make another batch. Looks like I may have about a 2 month wait for the 1.18s I want for mine. And I just sold my .920 bars yesterday!
Mopar to the bone!!!
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: kzinge1]
#1193498
04/05/12 10:08 AM
04/05/12 10:08 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,388 Pikes Peak Country
TC@HP2
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,388
Pikes Peak Country
|
While a four corner weight review is the ideal way to do it, you can get a good idea of front to rear bias with a simple truck scale. Landscaping suppliers, scrap metal dealers, drywall supply, junkyards, trucking companies, even some drag strips and oval tracks have basic drive on/off scales that can give you a rough idea of where you are at. I've seen data on the XHD saying they are around 130-140# rate. SS springs range from 130-160#. MP Oval track springs are 120#. Used up stock springs are maybe 50-120#, depending on how abused they were. FWIW, I believe the baseline Kit Car set up was 1" t-bars, 1" front s-bar and 120# rear leafs. XV Motorsports seems to have found that page in the Chassis manual as most of their level 1 set ups use t-bars in the 1.1 range, front sway bar in the 1.1 range, much lighter (but they wont say how much) leaf springs and a 7/8-1" axle hung rear sway bar. http://www.xvmotorsports.com/products/detail/index.cfm?nPID=279&cid=2&cdesc=Suspension
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: kzinge1]
#1193499
04/05/12 11:23 AM
04/05/12 11:23 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 1,645 Phila. Pa.
Mattax
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 1,645
Phila. Pa.
|
Place the spring on a level suface, arch up. Measure the distance from surface. Lets call it Free Height. Weigh yourself. This will be Weight. Holding on to something, carefully load the spring with your full weight. Remeasure from the surface to the same place on the spring pad as before. Call this Loaded Height. Carefully get off the spring while holding on to something (or you may get tossed).
Now do the math. Distance displaced = Free Height - Loaded Height Spring Rate = Weight / Distance Displaced
Weight is in pounds force, Distance in inches, therefore Spring rate will be in lbs/in. This is crude but approximately correct.
If you're a bit more ambitious, pull a string from eye center to eye center and measure the distance from the spring to the mounting pad. This is the free arch, or darn close to it.
After doing this, please share along with the exact part number of the springs. Other details you may wish to note is spring thickness (if you have a caliper or micrometer) number of full and partial leaves and bushing diameters. This will be good for your own reference but will also help others in the future.
Later you can do the same on your SS springs. In that case, you'll have to check both the left and right asthey may be different in free arch.
Last edited by Mattax; 04/05/12 11:26 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: Mattax]
#1193500
04/05/12 08:00 PM
04/05/12 08:00 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 22,696 Bitopia
jcc
If you can't dazzle em with diamonds..
|
If you can't dazzle em with diamonds..
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 22,696
Bitopia
|
Quote:
Place the spring on a level suface, arch up. Measure the distance from surface. Lets call it Free Height. Weigh yourself. This will be Weight. Holding on to something, carefully load the spring with your full weight. Remeasure from the surface to the same place on the spring pad as before. Call this Loaded Height. Carefully get off the spring while holding on to something (or you may get tossed).
So I won't get in hot water by saying the above is useful, but nearly shade tree?
The 3 biggest concerns, IMO to getting accuracy are, your relatively limited body weight ( Ok that's a guess), the difficulty in getting an accurate (take 3 and avg results) height measurement ( and the floor? must be very rigid), and the friction the inverted steel spring eyes encounter with the ground surface ( wood, dirt, rough concrete, etc) as leaf tries to flatten, additionally I am uncertain as to how much spring rate changes (softens?) as spring approaches a flat arch. Using a heavier weight (GF?) would improve accuracy.
Regardless, the above test is likely more accurate then simply guessing for comparisons sake.
And IMO, the the love affair here with rear sway bars, is best answered by the reply that states using a rear sway bar for is best for tuning, not as a fix for other issues. To give, IMO, some credence that a sway bar is not ALWAYS required, I believe the 90's GTP Sport cars Nissans, highly successful class champions, for Multi years, raced with zero sway bars. http://www.johnstarkeycars.com/pages/books/Nissan.html
|
|
|
Re: Beginner Suspension Upgrades *UPDATE-SWAYBAR INSTALLED
[Re: Viol8r]
#1193505
04/06/12 07:28 PM
04/06/12 07:28 PM
|
Joined: Feb 2012
Posts: 199 NC
1970A66
member
|
member
Joined: Feb 2012
Posts: 199
NC
|
Quote:
This is not enough front sway bar and front torsion bar to justify a 7/8 rear bar. I would consider staying away from the rear bar for now IMHO
I have to agree with this........based upon my conversation with Dick at Firm Feel. He didn't think it was necessary for my street only Challenger. He recommended his tubular upper control arms instead of the rear sway bar. The UCA's will allow for much improved handling by allowing for for more positive caster adjustment. I haven't bought them yet. I did buy his stage 2 box, Bilstein RCD shocks and sector shaft support bearing. Great stuff! The Bilsteins were a huge improvement for sure but I think the improvement I experienced won't be the same for the next guy. It depends on what you currently have on your car that you are replacing. Drag shocks, air shocks, cheap Monroes etc. Also if you do any other changes at the same time you install the Bilsteins, like I did.
I recommend you call Dick and talk to him, he will take his time and answer your questions based upon his vast experience!
|
|
|
|
|