Why the epidemic of failed new cams? - Moparts Forums

Register Log In Moparts Forums Moparts Question and Answer Why the epidemic of failed new cams?

Print Thread

Page 1 of 2

1

2

Why the epidemic of failed new cams? #1307322 09/20/12 10:17 AM 09/20/12 10:17 AM
Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL Commando1 OP master
Commando1 OP master Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL	I don't know if it's because I'm getting older and the stories are just accumulating or if there really has been an extreme epidemic of new cams getting wiped before the 2k mile mark. I've heard all the stories. Crap used in the Chinese forgings. Companies becoming the Walmart of valve trains and skipping on QA/QC. Oil formulation changes in the last few years for the worse. Plus the eternal ever standard: "did ya break it in properly?". It's happening in all the engines, from garage builds to pro builds. I wish ASTM would do a comprehensive study on this but that ain't gonna happen. The podium is now open....

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307323 09/20/12 10:32 AM 09/20/12 10:32 AM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 4,588 St. John's Newfoundland 440newport master
440newport master Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 4,588 St. John's Newfoundland	I don't think it's as bad as at used to be say, a few years ago but you still hear about it. I think the biggest reason was the new oil formulations that took the zinc and other things out of oil that flat tappet cams need. Most people in the hobby know about it by now, but it took a while for the average guy to realize that you can't just grab any old 10W-30 off the shelf to break in a cam anymore. There was also word of a bad batch of mopar lifters floating around a few years back. Many people say Johnson made/make the best quality lifters but I think they were out of buisness for a while, so we probably had a lot of soft Chinese junk out there repackaged as many different brands.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: 440newport] #1307324 09/20/12 11:28 AM 09/20/12 11:28 AM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 75,043 U.S.S.A. JohnRR I Win
JohnRR I Win Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 75,043 U.S.S.A.	Quote: There was also word of a bad batch of mopar lifters floating around a few years back. Many people say Johnson made/make the best quality lifters but I think they were out of buisness for a while, so we probably had a lot of soft Chinese junk out there repackaged as many different brands. The story I heard it wasn't just Mopar, it was across the board. I don't know the name of the company but one of remaining 2 or 3 makers went belly up and the company that came in to sell off the remains saw loads of lifters that didn't pass inspection and SOLD them off as good. Its takenn a number of years for those lifters to make it thru the systems ...

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: JohnRR] #1307325 09/20/12 12:20 PM 09/20/12 12:20 PM
Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 4,785 Utah and Alaska astjp2 master
astjp2 master Joined: Jan 2011 Posts: 4,785 Utah and Alaska	The Dello diesel oil has the right amount of ZDDP in it for breaking in a cam, it should still be around 1500ppm, much less and you wipe out a cam lobe because it lacks the anti skuffing compound. Also most people are not checking for lifter rotation before starting, some of the lifters were slightly oversize and do not rotate in the bore, a small ball hone fixes that problem. Tim

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: JohnRR] #1307326 09/20/12 02:41 PM 09/20/12 02:41 PM
Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL Commando1 OP master
Commando1 OP master Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL	Quote: I don't know the name of the company but one of remaining 2 or 3 makers went belly up and the company that came in to sell off the remains saw loads of lifters that didn't pass inspection and SOLD them off as good. Bain Capital? J/K

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307327 09/20/12 03:20 PM 09/20/12 03:20 PM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 75,043 U.S.S.A. JohnRR I Win
JohnRR I Win Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 75,043 U.S.S.A.	Quote: Quote: I don't know the name of the company but one of remaining 2 or 3 makers went belly up and the company that came in to sell off the remains saw loads of lifters that didn't pass inspection and SOLD them off as good. Bain Capital? J/K Didn't Bain buy struggling companies and not companies that folded ?

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: JohnRR] #1307328 09/20/12 03:42 PM 09/20/12 03:42 PM
Joined: Jun 2008 Posts: 3,916 usa L lewtot184 master
lewtot184 master L Joined: Jun 2008 Posts: 3,916 usa	eaton quit making flat tappets, johnson went out of business and the only people left were stanadyne, the worst in the business. i also think that people wanting very agressive lobes, especially hydraulic flat tappet, to use in production blocks was a factor. the oil thing was probably the "cherry" on top the sundae.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: lewtot184] #1307329 09/20/12 05:08 PM 09/20/12 05:08 PM
Joined: Feb 2003 Posts: 21,318 Manitoba, Canada DaytonaTurbo Too Many Posts
DaytonaTurbo Too Many Posts Joined: Feb 2003 Posts: 21,318 Manitoba, Canada	People using crap oils during break-in. People not follow break-in procedures properly. Modern cams have much more aggressive lobes than the lazy cams of yesteryear.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307330 09/20/12 05:11 PM 09/20/12 05:11 PM
Joined: Feb 2005 Posts: 28,312 Cincinnati, Ohio Challenger 1 Too Many Posts
Challenger 1 Too Many Posts Joined: Feb 2005 Posts: 28,312 Cincinnati, Ohio	I often wonder when I read about these failures if they are sometimes caused by improper setup. Wrong lash or preload. It seems a lot of people screw that up and then blame everything but themselves?

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307331 09/20/12 05:48 PM 09/20/12 05:48 PM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 16,376 D dogdays I Live Here
dogdays I Live Here D Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 16,376	Hasn't this issue been beaten TO DEATH? BTW, cast iron cams are used for flat tappets. R.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: dogdays] #1307332 09/20/12 06:20 PM 09/20/12 06:20 PM
Joined: Sep 2012 Posts: 180 3rd rock K kloyiod
kloyiod K Joined: Sep 2012 Posts: 180 3rd rock	If your wiping a cam, your using the wrong company cause they won't back their product! I've never had a problem. http://www.hughesengines.com/TechArticles/ourcamsareguaranteednottogoflat.php

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: DaytonaTurbo] #1307333 09/20/12 09:02 PM 09/20/12 09:02 PM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 5,186 Wherever I am. J Junky master
Junky master J Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 5,186 Wherever I am.	Quote: People using crap oils during break-in. People not follow break-in procedures properly. Modern cams have much more aggressive lobes than the lazy cams of yesteryear. Yeah, that. About 2 years ago I installed my first cam, a Hughes cam. Learned how to do it from moparts.com. Went just fine for me. 2010 Black Challenger SE <> 3.5 V6 Custom Shift Knobs www.flameball.com Check It Out

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: dogdays] #1307334 09/21/12 09:12 AM 09/21/12 09:12 AM
Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 1,880 Out in Left Field, NY B bobs66440 top fuel
bobs66440 top fuel B Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 1,880 Out in Left Field, NY	Quote: Hasn't this issue been beaten TO DEATH? BTW, cast iron cams are used for flat tappets. R. I don't think it's a bad idea to revisit these topics once in a while. It helps keep us updated on an ever changing subject and it makes it easier for guys (that this is a new problem to, like me) to get info on. I'm going through this right now (not a cam, but a lifter) and it's helpful (and sometimes confusing, lol) to get opinions...

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: bobs66440] #1307335 09/21/12 09:20 AM 09/21/12 09:20 AM
Joined: Feb 2004 Posts: 4,501 Gainesville,FL G goldmember master
goldmember master G Joined: Feb 2004 Posts: 4,501 Gainesville,FL	I don't see the problem getting a flat tappet cam to live. I broke in a hyd flat last week and expect it to live a long life. MOST cam failures are due to installer error(NOT ALL!). Use a quality cam,lifters and oil and quit over thinking it.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: dogdays] #1307336 09/22/12 09:34 AM 09/22/12 09:34 AM
Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL Commando1 OP master
Commando1 OP master Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL	Quote: Hasn't this issue been beaten TO DEATH? BTW, cast iron cams are used for flat tappets. R. Well, then, I don't want to see any more: 1. How good is a 440 Source (fill in the blank)... 2. Best rear main seal?... 3. Help! I have a bog in my carb coming off idle... 4. Edelbrock or Holley?

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307337 09/22/12 10:04 AM 09/22/12 10:04 AM
Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 1,880 Out in Left Field, NY B bobs66440 top fuel
bobs66440 top fuel B Joined: Mar 2010 Posts: 1,880 Out in Left Field, NY	Quote: Quote: Hasn't this issue been beaten TO DEATH? BTW, cast iron cams are used for flat tappets. R. Well, then, I don't want to see any more: 1. How good is a 440 Source (fill in the blank)... 2. Best rear main seal?... 3. Help! I have a bog in my carb coming off idle... 4. Edelbrock or Holley? Exactly. Part of the reason for this forum is to help people with problems. That means revisiting popular topics now and then...

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: bobs66440] #1307338 09/22/12 03:07 PM 09/22/12 03:07 PM
Joined: Jul 2003 Posts: 3,378 Rancho Cordova, CA Exit1965 master
Exit1965 master Joined: Jul 2003 Posts: 3,378 Rancho Cordova, CA	This topic is one of those with varying strong opinions either way, and the tough part is, there is no data (that I'm aware of) to say a) how many cams die b) how the above cams die I have run 3 hydraulic flat tappet cams in over the past 5 years, all had survived. If I had one of them bite the dust I'd probably be on the extreme of "never using one again" and go with a roller instead. The whole problem is probably overblown. The fact that it results in significant work to fix, makes doing things right even more important and may exaggerate how common it actually is. Just because everyone takes very careful steps to avoid it, doesn't automatically mean it's guaranteed to fail if you don't do things exactly by the book.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Commando1] #1307339 09/22/12 07:19 PM 09/22/12 07:19 PM
Joined: Jul 2008 Posts: 259 Khemi, Stygia Mebsuta enthusiast
Mebsuta enthusiast Joined: Jul 2008 Posts: 259 Khemi, Stygia	How many of the traditional, now considered lazy lobe, camshafts have failed? That was what this old stuff was originally designed to use. It kind of reminds me of AR-15 discussions. People thought they knew better than Gene Stoner and strayed away from the original design. They were not always successful. 68 Roadrunner. 383 4-spd. Beat up.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: kloyiod] #1307340 09/22/12 07:43 PM 09/22/12 07:43 PM
Joined: Jan 2004 Posts: 27,347 Today? Who Knows? 1_WILD_RT Management Trainee
1_WILD_RT Management Trainee Joined: Jan 2004 Posts: 27,347 Today? Who Knows?	Quote: If your wiping a cam, your using the wrong company cause they won't back their product! I've never had a problem. http://www.hughesengines.com/TechArticles/ourcamsareguaranteednottogoflat.php Thats Damn Funny Right There..... https://board.moparts.org/ubbthreads/show...part=1&vc=1 "The Armies of our ancestors were lucky, in that they were not trailed by a second army of pencil pushers."

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: kloyiod] #1307341 09/22/12 08:09 PM 09/22/12 08:09 PM
Joined: Sep 2007 Posts: 14,889 up yours Supercuda About to go away
Supercuda About to go away Joined: Sep 2007 Posts: 14,889 up yours	Quote: If your wiping a cam, your using the wrong company cause they won't back their product! I've never had a problem. http://www.hughesengines.com/TechArticles/ourcamsareguaranteednottogoflat.php Hee hee, I read this and said "he must be new here", 9 posts, guess so. They say there are no such thing as a stupid question. They say there is always the exception that proves the rule. Don't be the exception.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Supercuda] #1307342 09/24/12 01:02 PM 09/24/12 01:02 PM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 16,376 D dogdays I Live Here
dogdays I Live Here D Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 16,376	To: Commando1 If none of those topics ever showed up again I would be ecstatic. So thank you for putting it into words. R.

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: dogdays] #1307343 09/24/12 10:16 PM 09/24/12 10:16 PM
Joined: Feb 2005 Posts: 4,316 Prospect, PA BSB67 master
BSB67 master Joined: Feb 2005 Posts: 4,316 Prospect, PA	Quote: To: Commando1 If none of those topics ever showed up again I would be ecstatic. ...to name a few....

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: BSB67] #1307344 09/25/12 10:39 AM 09/25/12 10:39 AM
Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL Commando1 OP master
Commando1 OP master Joined: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,336 South-Central (Sebring), FL	Quote: Quote: To: Commando1 If none of those topics ever showed up again I would be ecstatic. ...to name a few.... Actually, I could come up with a list as long as your arm, BUT, I have asked a few questions in the past that probably seemed absolutely like rookie stuff to some, but guys came through and bailed out my sorry azz anyway. So.... to them I say Thank You and I try to remember there's no such thing as a stupid question. Except for: "Is this a scam...."

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: Supercuda] #1307345 09/25/12 02:01 PM 09/25/12 02:01 PM
Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 21,074 Niles , Ohio T therocks oh wait.but hey.lets see.oh yeah.
therocks oh wait.but hey.lets see.oh yeah. T Joined: Jan 2003 Posts: 21,074 Niles , Ohio	I agree most are from improper setup and down right neglect.Ive probally installed 20 in the past 12 years.Had 1 failure.The kid didnt want to seat the lifters,just installed and set the idle.Then he never changed the oil and ran it low after about 5000 miles.But it was the cams fault.I run either Kendall GT1 or Valvoline race oil.My radical solid is 14 years old and going strong.The sons 413 with Hughes cam is just as old and has more miles.Still like new.Rocky Chrysler Firepower

Re: Why the epidemic of failed new cams? [Re: therocks] #1307346 09/25/12 02:14 PM 09/25/12 02:14 PM
Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 12,419 Kalispell Mt. H HotRodDave I Live Here
HotRodDave I Live Here H Joined: Jan 2005 Posts: 12,419 Kalispell Mt.	I have never had one fail and have built lots of flat tappet engines. I ALWAYS make sure the lifters turn while I turn the engine. If I do not see one rotateing I pull it out and find the reason. Sometimes you have to polish the lifter body or scuff the face or something but they will rotate at hand turning speed. I am not causing global warming, I am just trying to hold off a impending Ice Age!

Page 1 of 2

1

2

Moderated by Al_Alguire, Hotwheelsjr, moparts, not_a_charger, RangerDan440, tboomer

Hop To

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1