Thanks, that's what I figured. I deleted my response to RPM because this thread would have gone way off of the rails. But I had poor results with RPM as well.
Looks like you've been around here for a while...It's a shame you can't tell the truth about using the product without the drama and banned member salesmanship that comes with every thread...Just for the record I've properly preped and done my own tests with it and have'nt gotten the expected results either...Let alone the members I've talked to with the same oppinion but don't want to feed the troll...
Eastwood makes a phosphate wash that would treat the metal for short term and works very well on the immediate flash rust but it does'nt hold up in the long run...Some have used a light oil{like a gun oil} on the parts but that requires reapplication and monotoring of the parts..
Clear will appear to do the job but eventually the rust will reappear and create a "spiderweb" type pattern looking very unnatural...
Pick your route and spin the wheel of luck...Until you've bought all the products no matter which route you take it would look much better and cost effective to just bite the bullet and have it replated if that's the original finish..