Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: Mr.Yuck]
#1262579
07/15/12 02:17 PM
07/15/12 02:17 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,826 NY usa
540challenger
master
|
master
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,826
NY usa
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
They are both Mopar so I like them both. But I know the 63 Max Wedge cars were street legal as anyone could buy one. I honestly feel in stock trim the Max Wedge was the fastest Mopar street muscle car sold in the muscle car era. Sure the Hemi was a race eng and would kick but when setup right but on the street in stock form it was held back and the wedge carried the banner for Mopar on the street most of the time. You have to ask yourself.........how many Hemi's did you see on the street in the 60's ? A stock Maxie 62 Dart 413 went 13.44 @ 109 for M/T. Good mph for a stock eng in 1962. 426 Maxie in 63 ran 12.60's @ almost 112 mph with just the cutouts open and Atlas tires. The Hemi to me was like Fords Boss 429 as it was choked out in stock form but was the king of all race engines where it dominated. The wedge had its place in Mopar history for sure and even ran good when prepped out. I dont know if my 63 would go any faster with a Hemi equipped the same as my wedge and thats because of the good heads out there for the wedge today. And everyone knows how well the 440 six pack cars ran on the street. And the Hemi dominated the first 2 years of Pro Stock so much they had to restrict it so GM and Ford could catch up. Ron
Well put, Ron.. and I agree..
Here is something else to think about.
My 71 Hemi Challenger was bought new by a guy with limited skills.
All he did was.
-Install headers. -12.5:1 pitons. -A Rat Roaster(unmodified) -Carter Competition series carbs -A Holley Red pump. -A Racer Brown solid cam -4.88 gears.
Car went 10.30's@134MPH. All stock suspension. Stock unmodded 4 speed, No spool. No headwork. Other than a big block Vette there probably isnt any musclecar that could go that fast with such relatively minor mods. Even ran the stock dual point distributor. No Chrysler wedge could do that, that I am aware of.
The Hemi really had it..
MB
sorry but a a 12.5:1 440 w/ a good inatke and carb(s) would run just as well... That's more than just a few bolt ons and far from the hemi's "stock" build. I'd probably run less gear w/ a 440 thou
I would like to see a 440 with stock heads run those numbers not a chance IMO. However with as cheap as aftermarket heads head go for a wedge you should be able to build one cheaper then a hemi. Dollar for HP i would pick a wedge hands done but Iam building myself a 3rd Gen hemi as we speak
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: Mr.Yuck]
#1262580
07/15/12 04:18 PM
07/15/12 04:18 PM
|
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 6,446 NJ-USA
HPMike
master
|
master
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 6,446
NJ-USA
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
They are both Mopar so I like them both. But I know the 63 Max Wedge cars were street legal as anyone could buy one. I honestly feel in stock trim the Max Wedge was the fastest Mopar street muscle car sold in the muscle car era. Sure the Hemi was a race eng and would kick but when setup right but on the street in stock form it was held back and the wedge carried the banner for Mopar on the street most of the time. You have to ask yourself.........how many Hemi's did you see on the street in the 60's ? A stock Maxie 62 Dart 413 went 13.44 @ 109 for M/T. Good mph for a stock eng in 1962. 426 Maxie in 63 ran 12.60's @ almost 112 mph with just the cutouts open and Atlas tires. The Hemi to me was like Fords Boss 429 as it was choked out in stock form but was the king of all race engines where it dominated. The wedge had its place in Mopar history for sure and even ran good when prepped out. I dont know if my 63 would go any faster with a Hemi equipped the same as my wedge and thats because of the good heads out there for the wedge today. And everyone knows how well the 440 six pack cars ran on the street. And the Hemi dominated the first 2 years of Pro Stock so much they had to restrict it so GM and Ford could catch up. Ron
Well put, Ron.. and I agree..
Here is something else to think about.
My 71 Hemi Challenger was bought new by a guy with limited skills.
All he did was.
-Install headers. -12.5:1 pitons. -A Rat Roaster(unmodified) -Carter Competition series carbs -A Holley Red pump. -A Racer Brown solid cam -4.88 gears.
Car went 10.30's@134MPH. All stock suspension. Stock unmodded 4 speed, No spool. No headwork. Other than a big block Vette there probably isnt any musclecar that could go that fast with such relatively minor mods. Even ran the stock dual point distributor. No Chrysler wedge could do that, that I am aware of.
The Hemi really had it..
MB
sorry but a a 12.5:1 440 w/ a good inatke and carb(s) would run just as well... That's more than just a few bolt ons and far from the hemi's "stock" build. I'd probably run less gear w/ a 440 thou
OK...So with your theory.
Take a stock full bodied 3,600# 440 Challenger with a non tricked stock 4 speed.
Put 12.5:1 pistons A set of headers. Lets say a Torker intake. An electric fuel pump. A solid cam with mid 70's technology, like the Racer Brown. An Edelbrock carb(just because the Competition Series Carters were just fancy versions of the original AFB's and were of the exact same design). Any gears you want. Dual point distributor. 100% stock suspension. Untouched 906 heads and the stock valvetrain.
With that recipe you are saying you would run 10.30's at 134?? Lets not forget, this was done in 1975 with just a regular guy building/tuning the car, not some guru....
MB
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: HPMike]
#1262581
07/15/12 05:10 PM
07/15/12 05:10 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 8,956 Holly/MI
Dean_Kuzluzski
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 8,956
Holly/MI
|
As true as ever........... as the old saying goes "it's hard to be humble when you own a Hemi". Undeniable, they 1st and 2nd Gen had their virtues. The 2nd being a race bred animal from its incarnation. But the wedges were the ones that the average masses massaged to defend the pentastar on the street as daily drivers back in the day. Never heard "Shoulda gotta Wedge" over the Hemi, but have heard "I can build several wedges for the cost of a Hemi" before! It's all good folks!
R.I.P.- Gary "Coop" Davis 02/09/68-05/13/04
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: HPMike]
#1262585
07/15/12 09:53 PM
07/15/12 09:53 PM
|
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 453 Holly, MI
JackGTX440
mopar
|
mopar
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 453
Holly, MI
|
Quote:
OK...So with your theory.
Take a stock full bodied 3,600# 440 Challenger with a non tricked stock 4 speed.
Put 12.5:1 pistons A set of headers. Lets say a Torker intake. An electric fuel pump. A solid cam with mid 70's technology, like the Racer Brown. An Edelbrock carb(just because the Competition Series Carters were just fancy versions of the original AFB's and were of the exact same design). Any gears you want. Dual point distributor. 100% stock suspension. Untouched 906 heads and the stock valvetrain.
With that recipe you are saying you would run 10.30's at 134?? Lets not forget, this was done in 1975 with just a regular guy building/tuning the car, not some guru....
MB
I agree, this sounds almost 2 seconds off... And about 16 mph... Just sayin'
I could however, see a HEMI car getting close to that.
Cost NOT included, the pros for the design of the HEMI FAR outweigh the cons.
Jack Irons Jr.
'67 GTX, turbo 6.1 HEMI
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: MoparBilly]
#1262586
07/15/12 10:04 PM
07/15/12 10:04 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,875 communist bloc of new jersey
jamesc
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,875
communist bloc of new jersey
|
Quote:
Wedge racer and driver...by choice! always have been, always will be. I have no problem with the Hemi, it's a fine engine, just not impressed with Hemi owners who think everyone should bow down and ooh and aah over their car because they have an engine that other people have done amazing things with.
agreed, they're ok but imho the hype outweighs the output. the SSH cars are impressive but as a general rule if you want to run a chrysler most are better off with a wedge. as for the newer PS type engine i think calling that a hemi is a bit of a stretch
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: HPMike]
#1262587
07/16/12 09:15 AM
07/16/12 09:15 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 24,562 Brookeville, Md
Mr.Yuck
Not enough dumb comments...yet
|
Not enough dumb comments...yet
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 24,562
Brookeville, Md
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
They are both Mopar so I like them both. But I know the 63 Max Wedge cars were street legal as anyone could buy one. I honestly feel in stock trim the Max Wedge was the fastest Mopar street muscle car sold in the muscle car era. Sure the Hemi was a race eng and would kick but when setup right but on the street in stock form it was held back and the wedge carried the banner for Mopar on the street most of the time. You have to ask yourself.........how many Hemi's did you see on the street in the 60's ? A stock Maxie 62 Dart 413 went 13.44 @ 109 for M/T. Good mph for a stock eng in 1962. 426 Maxie in 63 ran 12.60's @ almost 112 mph with just the cutouts open and Atlas tires. The Hemi to me was like Fords Boss 429 as it was choked out in stock form but was the king of all race engines where it dominated. The wedge had its place in Mopar history for sure and even ran good when prepped out. I dont know if my 63 would go any faster with a Hemi equipped the same as my wedge and thats because of the good heads out there for the wedge today. And everyone knows how well the 440 six pack cars ran on the street. And the Hemi dominated the first 2 years of Pro Stock so much they had to restrict it so GM and Ford could catch up. Ron
Well put, Ron.. and I agree..
Here is something else to think about.
My 71 Hemi Challenger was bought new by a guy with limited skills.
All he did was.
-Install headers. -12.5:1 pitons. -A Rat Roaster(unmodified) -Carter Competition series carbs -A Holley Red pump. -A Racer Brown solid cam -4.88 gears.
Car went 10.30's@134MPH. All stock suspension. Stock unmodded 4 speed, No spool. No headwork. Other than a big block Vette there probably isnt any musclecar that could go that fast with such relatively minor mods. Even ran the stock dual point distributor. No Chrysler wedge could do that, that I am aware of.
The Hemi really had it..
MB
sorry but a a 12.5:1 440 w/ a good inatke and carb(s) would run just as well... That's more than just a few bolt ons and far from the hemi's "stock" build. I'd probably run less gear w/ a 440 thou
OK...So with your theory.
Take a stock full bodied 3,600# 440 Challenger with a non tricked stock 4 speed.
Put 12.5:1 pistons A set of headers. Lets say a Torker intake. An electric fuel pump. A solid cam with mid 70's technology, like the Racer Brown. An Edelbrock carb(just because the Competition Series Carters were just fancy versions of the original AFB's and were of the exact same design). Any gears you want. Dual point distributor. 100% stock suspension. Untouched 906 heads and the stock valvetrain.
With that recipe you are saying you would run 10.30's at 134?? Lets not forget, this was done in 1975 with just a regular guy building/tuning the car, not some guru....
MB
So you get 2 carbs and I'm stuck w/ one pitiful carter? How about a short Ram w/ 2 holleys or a factory 6-pack? Probably do at least a home port job on the heads and run old isky rockers...I mean you're tearing the motor apart anyway right. My main point was your hemi was not stock. And the wedge might not be at 10.30 but It wouldn't be too far behind. Remember it doesn't need to see 7000rpm.
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: Mr.Yuck]
#1262588
07/16/12 10:10 AM
07/16/12 10:10 AM
|
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 6,446 NJ-USA
HPMike
master
|
master
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 6,446
NJ-USA
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
They are both Mopar so I like them both. But I know the 63 Max Wedge cars were street legal as anyone could buy one. I honestly feel in stock trim the Max Wedge was the fastest Mopar street muscle car sold in the muscle car era. Sure the Hemi was a race eng and would kick but when setup right but on the street in stock form it was held back and the wedge carried the banner for Mopar on the street most of the time. You have to ask yourself.........how many Hemi's did you see on the street in the 60's ? A stock Maxie 62 Dart 413 went 13.44 @ 109 for M/T. Good mph for a stock eng in 1962. 426 Maxie in 63 ran 12.60's @ almost 112 mph with just the cutouts open and Atlas tires. The Hemi to me was like Fords Boss 429 as it was choked out in stock form but was the king of all race engines where it dominated. The wedge had its place in Mopar history for sure and even ran good when prepped out. I dont know if my 63 would go any faster with a Hemi equipped the same as my wedge and thats because of the good heads out there for the wedge today. And everyone knows how well the 440 six pack cars ran on the street. And the Hemi dominated the first 2 years of Pro Stock so much they had to restrict it so GM and Ford could catch up. Ron
Well put, Ron.. and I agree..
Here is something else to think about.
My 71 Hemi Challenger was bought new by a guy with limited skills.
All he did was.
-Install headers. -12.5:1 pitons. -A Rat Roaster(unmodified) -Carter Competition series carbs -A Holley Red pump. -A Racer Brown solid cam -4.88 gears.
Car went 10.30's@134MPH. All stock suspension. Stock unmodded 4 speed, No spool. No headwork. Other than a big block Vette there probably isnt any musclecar that could go that fast with such relatively minor mods. Even ran the stock dual point distributor. No Chrysler wedge could do that, that I am aware of.
The Hemi really had it..
MB
sorry but a a 12.5:1 440 w/ a good inatke and carb(s) would run just as well... That's more than just a few bolt ons and far from the hemi's "stock" build. I'd probably run less gear w/ a 440 thou
OK...So with your theory.
Take a stock full bodied 3,600# 440 Challenger with a non tricked stock 4 speed.
Put 12.5:1 pistons A set of headers. Lets say a Torker intake. An electric fuel pump. A solid cam with mid 70's technology, like the Racer Brown. An Edelbrock carb(just because the Competition Series Carters were just fancy versions of the original AFB's and were of the exact same design). Any gears you want. Dual point distributor. 100% stock suspension. Untouched 906 heads and the stock valvetrain.
With that recipe you are saying you would run 10.30's at 134?? Lets not forget, this was done in 1975 with just a regular guy building/tuning the car, not some guru....
MB
So you get 2 carbs and I'm stuck w/ one pitiful carter? How about a short Ram w/ 2 holleys or a factory 6-pack? Probably do at least a home port job on the heads and run old isky rockers...I mean you're tearing the motor apart anyway right. My main point was your hemi was not stock. And the wedge might not be at 10.30 but It wouldn't be too far behind. Remember it doesn't need to see 7000rpm.
Who said the Hemi was stock??
But my comparison is "apples to apples". The hemi comes from the factory with two carbs, so you arent adding anything. Add carbs to your wedge and you are. All I am trying to illustrate is that you arent going to get nearly as far with the equivalent work on a wedge as you would a Hemi. Period. And when you start really turning up the heat, then the wedge really gets left behind. The wedge then needs serious aftermarket parts. There is a reason these cars got their own classification in Super Stock. It was otherwise an unfair advantage to anything else. And the wedge is actually a "bigger" engine technically speaking.
MB
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: 383man]
#1262591
07/16/12 05:36 PM
07/16/12 05:36 PM
|
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 2,275 Desert Tracker
HYPER8oSoNic
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 2,275
Desert Tracker
|
Quote:
Stock heads would hold the wedge back for sure. We have very good aftermarket and MP wedge heads but you cant consider it stock anymore once you put Indy's or Eddy heads on a 440. You have to add a good head to the wedge to try and stay even close to the Hemi. Ron
Great points, Ron!! But...there IS enough factory and aftermarket performance goodies for the wedge to "do battle" with the HEMI. Biggest problem is not the power, nor the breathing capabilities as much as everyone believes. It's the engine reliability and hi-rpm potential. The wedge is bit behind in both areas. The HEMI heads are simply "free-breathers" at higher rpms, netting MORE hp than the wedge. Not to say the wedge cannot attain high levels of hp, they simply do it at a lower rpm level than the HEMI. That's why I believe the wedges NEED the added preventative measures and parts (precise lower end clearances, billet/steel main bearing caps, main bearing/block girdles, cross-bolted main cap engine blocks), to complete with the HEMI and it's reliability/power output. Again, simply put (and without insult to ANYONE), wedges (max or not) RULE the 8.90's (oops SS wedges are near 8.60-8.50 now?)and slower brackets and classes, while the HEMIS dominate everything else. Except the STREETS, where the CROWN can go to either motor, if it's fair. But..who knows what IS fair!!
"Stupidity is Ignorance on Steroids" "Yeah, it's hopped to over 160" (quote by Kowalski in the movie Vanishing Point 1970 - Cupid Productions)
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: HPMike]
#1262592
07/16/12 06:17 PM
07/16/12 06:17 PM
|
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 2,275 Desert Tracker
HYPER8oSoNic
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 2,275
Desert Tracker
|
Quote:
Quote:
They are both Mopar so I like them both. But I know the 63 Max Wedge cars were street legal as anyone could buy one. I honestly feel in stock trim the Max Wedge was the fastest Mopar street muscle car sold in the muscle car era. Sure the Hemi was a race eng and would kick but when setup right but on the street in stock form it was held back and the wedge carried the banner for Mopar on the street most of the time. You have to ask yourself.........how many Hemi's did you see on the street in the 60's ? A stock Maxie 62 Dart 413 went 13.44 @ 109 for M/T. Good mph for a stock eng in 1962. 426 Maxie in 63 ran 12.60's @ almost 112 mph with just the cutouts open and Atlas tires. The Hemi to me was like Fords Boss 429 as it was choked out in stock form but was the king of all race engines where it dominated. The wedge had its place in Mopar history for sure and even ran good when prepped out. I dont know if my 63 would go any faster with a Hemi equipped the same as my wedge and thats because of the good heads out there for the wedge today. And everyone knows how well the 440 six pack cars ran on the street. And the Hemi dominated the first 2 years of Pro Stock so much they had to restrict it so GM and Ford could catch up. Ron
Well put, Ron.. and I agree..
Here is something else to think about.
My 71 Hemi Challenger was bought new by a guy with limited skills.
All he did was.
-Install headers. -12.5:1 pitons. -A Rat Roaster(unmodified) -Carter Competition series carbs -A Holley Red pump. -A Racer Brown solid cam -4.88 gears.
Car went 10.30's@134MPH. All stock suspension. Stock unmodded 4 speed, No spool. No headwork. Other than a big block Vette there probably isnt any musclecar that could go that fast with such relatively minor mods. Even ran the stock dual point distributor. No Chrysler wedge could do that, that I am aware of.
The Hemi really had it..
MB
Mike, all that your friend did was "UNCORK" the power output of the HEMI. It (Street Hemi) was ALREADY fortified and de-tuned (set up for lesser power output) for street use from the factory. Compared to a 440 6 pack and 4-bbl Magnum motors it's a production "race piece" for the street, along with the Stage I 413, Stage II 413/426 and the legendary Stage III 426 MaxWedge motor (dubbed:"The Orange Monster") and the ACTUAL 426 Race HEMI of '64. Umm..Hemi power pulling through a (now vintage) Rat Roaster intake to a 4speed and 4.88 gears on stock HEMI springs, no snubber. Any problems off the line hooking up?
"Stupidity is Ignorance on Steroids" "Yeah, it's hopped to over 160" (quote by Kowalski in the movie Vanishing Point 1970 - Cupid Productions)
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: HYPER8oSoNic]
#1262593
07/16/12 07:36 PM
07/16/12 07:36 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030 Trumbull,CT.
jim sciortino
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030
Trumbull,CT.
|
There is an "easy" way to settle this discussion if there is a millionare (or 2) out there looking to drop about 250K into a fun shootout. 4 engines total, dyno sessions to maximize the combinations and I'll supply the car put em' in, to avoid the "we don't race dyno" arguement. 2 engines with stock blocks, heads and strokes......anything else goes. Max Wedge head vs HEMI head. 2 engines with aftermarket blocks (4.800BS), best straight head for the wedge (raw PSO) and best conventional HEMI head (raw Millennium). Billet intakes, dual doms, dry sump, lobe relocation, anything and everything......max N/A on all 4 engines. Have two top builders assemble the 2 engines they specialize in.....say Best Machine for the wedge and Ray Barton for the HEMI. Come on millionares......step up and let's settle this age old question.
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: RSNOMO]
#1262595
07/16/12 07:57 PM
07/16/12 07:57 PM
|
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 5,620 long island NY
Ari440
master
|
master
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 5,620
long island NY
|
I like the fact that you are trying to compare a wedge to a hemi
two diffrent motors
1.39 9.85 - 137 mph
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: RSNOMO]
#1262596
07/16/12 07:58 PM
07/16/12 07:58 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030 Trumbull,CT.
jim sciortino
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030
Trumbull,CT.
|
Quote:
If'n it was gonna be a wedge, I'd have to go with Jim Hale, or Dan Dvorak...
I have no preference, but Best Machine knows those PSO heads pretty well.
|
|
|
Re: Hemi vs Wedge
[Re: Ari440]
#1262597
07/16/12 08:07 PM
07/16/12 08:07 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030 Trumbull,CT.
jim sciortino
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 2,030
Trumbull,CT.
|
Quote:
I like the fact that you are trying to compare a wedge to a hemi
two diffrent motors
I'm not.....I know quite well just how different the requirements are for a good HEMI build and I know how easy it is to apply conventional wedge style procedures that turn HEMIs into toilet bowls.
I have a W-8 and a HEMI and had a 440-1. They all run/ran fine.......I like em' all.
I just think a shootout like this would be a ton-o-fun for the MOPAR crowd. Albeit a bit pricey.
|
|
|
|
|