My concern about the finish is, if they are chromed and get slightly damaged (dinged), your repair options are very limited outside of re-chroming. Whereas if they are polished like the originals, repair would be an option available to most of the owners.
From what I have seen, the new ones look to be flash chromed. If that is the case, how well are they going to hold up?

It would be nice to get some side by side comparisons. It is very difficult to get decent comparison pictures of parts with reflective surfaces, so this may be an unrealistic request.