5-years later there should be some answers now to all the questions asked in this thread.
Tom
So, 5 years later, the answers are:
1. PorkyPig is an a-hole
2. BradH is an idiot
3. Trick Flow is better out of the box
4. Both intakes are comparable if fully ported
Tony Bischoff did an Engine Masters Mopar entry some years ago where I saw pics of the engine using both intakes at different times. I believe he went with the Edelbrock because Trick Flow wasn't paying sponsorship bonus for their intake, but Edelbrock was.