We have tested the smaller Barton vs the smaller Indy on a 484 Hemi, and both ran very close...The smaller Indy we did have a 1" spacer on it. Plugs from either looked great...The weight difference between them was unreal though...
I have not tested the 4500's against each other. Its taken me a while just to get my junk to run. I hope to enjoy it a little more this year.