Ok, so got it out. I think the pictures below explain it all. I think my repair job will hold up just fine, let me know what you think.

IMG_4876.jpg
I think this is supposed to be attached.

IMG_4884.jpg
Everyone knows black duct tape is superior to the standard silver tape, so I think I got this covered.

IMG_4882.jpg
Best part about it, it blends right in, so I don't even have to repaint!