Here are the photos: Passenger side fits much better than the drivers side. I ended up having to shim both sides (which I hate to do) but it was the only way to get the bumper to even come close to fitting. I also had to "tweak" the bumper brackets a little.
The bumper was fine, the brackets were fine/ no damage. I'm 99% sure most of the issues were from the repro (older china repro) quarters and the guy who installed them.