I just went through something sorta similar to this with a new fuel tank and sending unit for my '69 Charger R/T. After installing the new sending unit, then installing the tank in the car, I had a leak at the sending unit(?). Dropped the new tank, pulled the sending unit to replace the gasket with another new one, and discovered the new tank had a split approx. 3-8ths of an inch at the bottom of the hole where the sending unit installs! Was using a borrowed lift, so had no choice but to "repair" on the spot, using Permatex fuel tank sealer. Huge disappointment, considering it was a new tank, sending unit, etc., but it did stop the leak. Now I don't have any confidence in the new tank, dammit! I'll sure as hell check the next tank more closely before I install it!