Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2
good aluminum bb waterpump ? #1997447
01/24/16 01:11 AM
01/24/16 01:11 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,743
central new york
pettyblue440 Offline OP
master
pettyblue440  Offline OP
master

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,743
central new york
who makes a good aluminum water pump? I remember reading there were some bad ones going around a while back. thanks ,jon

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1997465
01/24/16 01:45 AM
01/24/16 01:45 AM
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
R
RapidRobert Offline
Circle Track
RapidRobert  Offline
Circle Track
R

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
You might check out 440 sources' offerings. I have one of there blems & its gonna be easy to open up the "blem" restriction. I ain't fitted it/mocked up to the block yet to see if everything (bolt holes/ports etc) is copacetic on the rest of it. iirc its ~ $49. I think shipping is free on $99 or more if you see something else there you need


live every 24 hour block of time like it's your last day on earth
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: RapidRobert] #1997505
01/24/16 03:05 AM
01/24/16 03:05 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,350
Aurora, Oh.
M
max_maniac Offline
master
max_maniac  Offline
master
M

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,350
Aurora, Oh.
I have one of the Mancini ones and they are nice and reasonable on price0

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1997539
01/24/16 08:00 AM
01/24/16 08:00 AM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
The 440 Source housing from roughly 5 to 7 years ago had too small of passages to the lower engine block holes and definitely caused a restriction.

I have one of that version housing and have been dealing with running hot issues that changing most everything else hasn't fixed. (waterpump, thermostat, fan clutch all several times)

In a stock housing you can easily put your finger in through the front water pump area and into the curve where it goes to the block.

That's not possible with the older 440 Source version.

I just bought one of their new revised versions, the passages are definitely larger than the previous ones.
$65 shipped.


I haven't taken it over to the garage to compare it to a factory iron one.

If it's about the same size ports as the factory one I'll be installing it as is.

If it needs any reworking to make the ports larger I'll be doing that.

I'll post about it either way.

Hopefully it cures the run hot issues.

Last edited by Sputnik; 01/24/16 11:56 PM.

Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1997585
01/24/16 11:57 AM
01/24/16 11:57 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 21,071
Niles , Ohio
T
therocks Offline
oh wait.but hey.lets see.oh yeah.
therocks  Offline
oh wait.but hey.lets see.oh yeah.
T

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 21,071
Niles , Ohio
Housing or pump?There is a difference.I run an old MP housing I bought 20 years ago used.Pump I run a Mopar piece.Been in at least 15 years and still great.Rocky


Chrysler Firepower
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1997724
01/24/16 04:00 PM
01/24/16 04:00 PM
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 5,399
Aurora, Colorado
451Mopar Offline
master
451Mopar  Offline
master

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 5,399
Aurora, Colorado
The PRW pump/housing worked good om my 505 stroker. Not sure how or if it is any different the the 440 source ones?https://www.prwonlinestore.com/product/1474400-high-performance-aluminum-water-pump

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: SNK-EYZ] #1998089
01/25/16 12:48 AM
01/25/16 12:48 AM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
I did a side by side comparison of the big block water pump housings and here's what I found.

The older restrictive 440 Source housing has seriously restrictive small lower passages where it turns going to the engine block.
The passage size is roughly 3/8th of an inch, roughly 1/2 the size of a factory cast iron housing.
You can barely get your pinkie finger into the lower water passages through the center hole where the water pump bolts on.
Waaay to small.

No amount of grinding with a carbide bit would ever be able to get the passages to the size of a factory housing. You would grind through the wall long before it was larger enough.

On a mild stock type engine they might work okay, but on a stroker motor like mine it would never let it flow enough.

The factory cast iron housing passages are large and roughly 5/8th of an inch. You can easily put any finger into the passage from the front with room to spare.

The new 440 Source housing passages are roughly 9/16th of an inch in size. A tiny bit smaller than the cast iron housing but waaay larger that the earlier versions.

I used a carbide bit to open it up a bit and smooth the corners of the passages.
By he time I was done it should flow the same as a factory housing.

What may be kind of humorous is I asked 440 Source about the earlier restrictive housings and I was told that only one passage was too small and restrictive. Not two passages like I was telling them. laugh2

Both lower passages on the early version are about 1/2 the size of the new version from 440 Source.


Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: SNK-EYZ] #1998211
01/25/16 04:53 AM
01/25/16 04:53 AM
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
R
RapidRobert Offline
Circle Track
RapidRobert  Offline
Circle Track
R

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
I just checked my "blem" again & one side is somewhat restricted and the other side is severely restricted! I'm definitely gonna have to go in the side & grind (& measure wall thickness) then plug the opening with (likely) a 1/2 NPT plug


live every 24 hour block of time like it's your last day on earth
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: RapidRobert] #1998486
01/25/16 04:33 PM
01/25/16 04:33 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,376
D
dogdays Offline
I Live Here
dogdays  Offline
I Live Here
D

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,376
You guys seem to believe that water flows like toothpaste out of a tube. It doesn't. It's a liquid, not a semi-liquid. The pump gives energy to the water, and the energy can be in the form of pressure or velocity (or temperature for that matter). This energy changes from pressure to velocity when the flow encounters a smaller cross-section, and changes from velocity to pressure when the cross-section increases.

But there's no free lunch. The restriction costs some energy, and a lot of that loss is from the sudden change in cross-section, both entrance and exit. So the best way to use those housings with the restrictions is to make the restrictions as large as you safely can, then make gradual transitions to the larger sizes both upstream and downstream of the restriction itself. Think venturi-like shapes.

On to heat load: If you're not using the extra horsepower your stroker is capable of, the power being generated is the same. The amount of heat rejected into the coolant COULD increase by the proportional increase in cylinder wall area, except that most of the heat comes from the head. The extra surface uncovered by the piston is at the bottom of the water jacket, and that's where temperatures are lowest. Also there's the extra friction caused by the longer stroke, meaning both longer piston travel and faster piston speeds.

It is my educated guess that the extra heat load from your stroker is no more than proportional to the displacement increase, and probably less. If you increased the compression ratio and increased thermal efficiency it may be quite a bit lower than directly proportional.

What this means is that a stroker doesn't necessarily reject a lot more heat into the coolant than the engine from which it was derived.

R.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1998508
01/25/16 05:01 PM
01/25/16 05:01 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
S
Stanton Offline
Don't question me!
Stanton  Offline
Don't question me!
S

Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
Quote:
No amount of grinding with a carbide bit would ever be able to get the passages to the size of a factory housing. You would grind through the wall long before it was larger enough.


Not true, the exterior dimensions are virtually identical therefore you could potentially grind the passages to the factory size. BUT, having done this, I can tell you that you're better off buying a housing with large passages in the first place. Its extremely difficult to get into the angles of the passages and you'd end up spending more on a selection of bits that you will on the proper housing.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: dogdays] #1998541
01/25/16 06:08 PM
01/25/16 06:08 PM
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,154
bethlehem pa
M
mikemee1331 Offline
master
mikemee1331  Offline
master
M

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 4,154
bethlehem pa
Originally Posted By dogdays
You guys seem to believe that water flows like toothpaste out of a tube. It doesn't. It's a liquid, not a semi-liquid. The pump gives energy to the water, and the energy can be in the form of pressure or velocity (or temperature for that matter). This energy changes from pressure to velocity when the flow encounters a smaller cross-section, and changes from velocity to pressure when the cross-section increases.

But there's no free lunch. The restriction costs some energy, and a lot of that loss is from the sudden change in cross-section, both entrance and exit. So the best way to use those housings with the restrictions is to make the restrictions as large as you safely can, then make gradual transitions to the larger sizes both upstream and downstream of the restriction itself. Think venturi-like shapes.

On to heat load: If you're not using the extra horsepower your stroker is capable of, the power being generated is the same. The amount of heat rejected into the coolant COULD increase by the proportional increase in cylinder wall area, except that most of the heat comes from the head. The extra surface uncovered by the piston is at the bottom of the water jacket, and that's where temperatures are lowest. Also there's the extra friction caused by the longer stroke, meaning both longer piston travel and faster piston speeds.

It is my educated guess that the extra heat load from your stroker is no more than proportional to the displacement increase, and probably less. If you increased the compression ratio and increased thermal efficiency it may be quite a bit lower than directly proportional.

What this means is that a stroker doesn't necessarily reject a lot more heat into the coolant than the engine from which it was derived.

R.



OMG! i get that and iagree

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: Stanton] #1998558
01/25/16 07:01 PM
01/25/16 07:01 PM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
Originally Posted By Stanton
Quote:
No amount of grinding with a carbide bit would ever be able to get the passages to the size of a factory housing. You would grind through the wall long before it was larger enough.


Not true, the exterior dimensions are virtually identical therefore you could potentially grind the passages to the factory size. BUT, having done this, I can tell you that you're better off buying a housing with large passages in the first place. Its extremely difficult to get into the angles of the passages and you'd end up spending more on a selection of bits that you will on the proper housing.


Incorrect/wrong, the exterior of the earlier housing are smaller/different that a factory cast iron housing.
The factory cast iron housing is rounder out further or cast larger in that area of the housing.

The housings were designed to bolt on and have all the machined areas in the proper locations, but they are cast different.
There's no mistaking them for a factory casting of any kind.

I'll have to take pics and post them showing the differences.


Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1998561
01/25/16 07:07 PM
01/25/16 07:07 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
S
Stanton Offline
Don't question me!
Stanton  Offline
Don't question me!
S

Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
Quote:
I'll have to take pics and post them showing the differences.


Yes, you better do that.

On the 440Source casting I had (about 5 years ago) I hogged it out enough to easily get my thumb in and never came close to breaking through the walls. The toughest part to grind is the slotted opening to the impeller and that's virtually impossible but the rest was no problem with a selection of cutters.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: dogdays] #1998568
01/25/16 07:21 PM
01/25/16 07:21 PM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
Originally Posted By dogdays
You guys seem to believe that water flows like toothpaste out of a tube. It doesn't. It's a liquid, not a semi-liquid. The pump gives energy to the water, and the energy can be in the form of pressure or velocity (or temperature for that matter). This energy changes from pressure to velocity when the flow encounters a smaller cross-section, and changes from velocity to pressure when the cross-section increases.

But there's no free lunch. The restriction costs some energy, and a lot of that loss is from the sudden change in cross-section, both entrance and exit. So the best way to use those housings with the restrictions is to make the restrictions as large as you safely can, then make gradual transitions to the larger sizes both upstream and downstream of the restriction itself. Think venturi-like shapes.

On to heat load: If you're not using the extra horsepower your stroker is capable of, the power being generated is the same. The amount of heat rejected into the coolant COULD increase by the proportional increase in cylinder wall area, except that most of the heat comes from the head. The extra surface uncovered by the piston is at the bottom of the water jacket, and that's where temperatures are lowest. Also there's the extra friction caused by the longer stroke, meaning both longer piston travel and faster piston speeds.

It is my educated guess that the extra heat load from your stroker is no more than proportional to the displacement increase, and probably less. If you increased the compression ratio and increased thermal efficiency it may be quite a bit lower than directly proportional.

What this means is that a stroker doesn't necessarily reject a lot more heat into the coolant than the engine from which it was derived.

R.



I understand that an engine stock ci or stroker is going to build more heat when under max load and building the most HP.
Building HP creates heat, pretty simple.

You're not going to convince me that putting a flow restriction by reducing the size of a port in 1/2 (two in this case) isn't going to reduce heat transfer (from the block to the coolant and then to the radiator).
If the flow is restricted then the transfer isn't going to happen like it should.

In my case the radiator is at 155 degrees, the block is at 230+ degrees in warm weather.
The heat isn't getting pulled out of the block more than likely because the flow is restricted.
It's an 11-1 compression street build 572 Hemi with aluminum heads, nothing that radical.
4 core 26 inch Champion aluminum radiator.
Even with the thermostat out you can barely see the coolant flow in the radiator.

The only thing that hasn't been changed to fix it has been the housing.
Once it's all back together I'll know for sure if that was the problem.

If there wasn't a problem, why did 440 Source retool a new version with larger passages?


Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: SNK-EYZ] #1998705
01/25/16 10:47 PM
01/25/16 10:47 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
S
Stanton Offline
Don't question me!
Stanton  Offline
Don't question me!
S

Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 8,870
Ontario, Canada
Quote:
If there wasn't a problem, why did 440 Source retool a new version with larger passages?


Everything 440Source sells gets a bad rap here because its made in China ... doesn't matter that the quality is pretty damn good for the price and that the majority of stuff will easily survive the intended purpose. Likewise with their pump housings. Someone took a look in one and noticed the difference in passage sizes and it went viral from there. Despite a number of people using the housings with absolutely no detrimental affect, the vocal majority prevailed. So if you're 440Source, what do you do? On your next production run you cave to the whining loudmouth schmucks.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: SNK-EYZ] #1998711
01/25/16 10:52 PM
01/25/16 10:52 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,376
D
dogdays Offline
I Live Here
dogdays  Offline
I Live Here
D

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,376
I'm glad you don't want me to convince you, I give up. You choose to ignore fluid dynamics, that's your loss, not mine. And don't bother to snark back, I really couldn't care less what you think.

Why did they retool? To make a better product. Simple.

Just because I said it could be made to work doesn't mean I think there isn't some optimization that should be done. And to 440Source's credit, they did.

R.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: pettyblue440] #1998746
01/26/16 12:04 AM
01/26/16 12:04 AM
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 566
WA
T
tman Offline
mopar
tman  Offline
mopar
T

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 566
WA
I'm thinking the OP is asking about the WATER PUMP.

Re: good aluminum bb waterpump ? [Re: dogdays] #1998838
01/26/16 03:32 AM
01/26/16 03:32 AM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
Originally Posted By dogdays
I'm glad you don't want me to convince you, I give up. You choose to ignore fluid dynamics, that's your loss, not mine. And don't bother to snark back, I really couldn't care less what you think.

Why did they retool? To make a better product. Simple.

Just because I said it could be made to work doesn't mean I think there isn't some optimization that should be done. And to 440Source's credit, they did.

R.


Yet you snark back with your reply. laugh2

I didn't know that anything in my reply was "snarky".

If you took it that way, that's on you. wave

I was simply stating the facts as I saw them.

It's seems pretty simple if you want more flow volume without raising the pressure you increase the size of the passage and have a pump that can handle the flow..


Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good alum bb waterpump ? Pics showing differences. [Re: Stanton] #1999264
01/26/16 08:35 PM
01/26/16 08:35 PM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
SNK-EYZ Offline
I Live Here
SNK-EYZ  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 10,132
A Red State
Originally Posted By Stanton
Quote:
I'll have to take pics and post them showing the differences.


Yes, you better do that.

On the 440Source casting I had (about 5 years ago) I hogged it out enough to easily get my thumb in and never came close to breaking through the walls. The toughest part to grind is the slotted opening to the impeller and that's virtually impossible but the rest was no problem with a selection of cutters.


Here are some pics showing the size difference.

The difference isn't on the front side, it's on the back where it faces the engine block.

Side by side of older 440 Source and a factory cart iron.


Measuring the cast iron one.


Measuring the older 440 Source before adjusting the caliper.


Measuring after adjusting the caliper.


I don't see any way to grind that one out to have the same size passage as a factory one.

I still need to take pics of the new 440 Source version.


Kayse can't keep up at all now. lol
Re: good alum bb waterpump ? Pics showing differences. [Re: SNK-EYZ] #1999315
01/26/16 09:57 PM
01/26/16 09:57 PM
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
R
RapidRobert Offline
Circle Track
RapidRobert  Offline
Circle Track
R

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,040
Lincoln Nebraska
Sputnik, good pics/measurements/info. After all this what I'm gonna do is measure/hog out my blem/break it in with the iron housing/iron pump/then swap on the alum housing then the alum scroll ("source") pump (one at a time) & keep an eye on what changes (hopefully nothing) on the water temps


live every 24 hour block of time like it's your last day on earth
Page 1 of 2 1 2






Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1