Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: radar]
#1671975
09/20/14 02:20 AM
09/20/14 02:20 AM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972 Romeo MI
MR_P_BODY
Master
|
Master
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972
Romeo MI
|
The only thing you didnt do when you ground on them.. you should have used some finer tootsie rolls to eliminate the rough stress risers and radius it.. you most likely wont have any issues with low spring pressure and low rpm as you are... I've ground on rockers also for clearance with mucher higher spring pressures and a couple thousand more rpm and they still havent failed... just remember any sharp edge is a break point
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: radar]
#1671976
09/20/14 03:05 AM
09/20/14 03:05 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,591 Canton, Ohio
Sport440
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,591
Canton, Ohio
|
Quote:
Geez I only took like .035 out of it in the deepest spot, which is where the witness marks were, then smoothed out the notch a little.
Should I call Larry Shepard to come get in line for head smacks?
He seemed to grind the bs out of those 273 rockers in his 'how to hot rod small block mopar engines' book! The builds on moparts all seem to run .6"+ lift cams though so if that's your point of reference I get it.
Btw this is all in good fun for me I am having a ball and always learn more with each engine I build or part I upgrade.
, Radar, I like your sense of humor.
Oh, Im, sure Larry would get in line for that.
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: MR_P_BODY]
#1671977
09/20/14 03:58 AM
09/20/14 03:58 AM
|
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,682 Philadelphia
radar
OP
top fuel
|
OP
top fuel
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,682
Philadelphia
|
Quote:
The only thing you didnt do when you ground on them.. you should have used some finer tootsie rolls to eliminate the rough stress risers and radius it.. you most likely wont have any issues with low spring pressure and low rpm as you are... I've ground on rockers also for clearance with mucher higher spring pressures and a couple thousand more rpm and they still havent failed... just remember any sharp edge is a break point
Mr. P- Thanks so much not for telling me it's ok but for offering constructive advice. I mocked them up for the last time just now with the new pushrods and ran the valves. The adjusters are all showing 1-1.5 threads on the bottom so I'm happy with my pushrod length. The retainers don't want to hit. Next is measuring them for side to side clearance and laying out shims before installation.
So I'll definitely get them all smooth with some sandpaper tootsie rolls when they come off this last time.
Bedtime for me gotta wake up and make the doughnuts!
Radar
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: radar]
#1671978
09/20/14 04:25 AM
09/20/14 04:25 AM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972 Romeo MI
MR_P_BODY
Master
|
Master
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972
Romeo MI
|
Quote:
Quote:
The only thing you didnt do when you ground on them.. you should have used some finer tootsie rolls to eliminate the rough stress risers and radius it.. you most likely wont have any issues with low spring pressure and low rpm as you are... I've ground on rockers also for clearance with mucher higher spring pressures and a couple thousand more rpm and they still havent failed... just remember any sharp edge is a break point
Mr. P- Thanks so much not for telling me it's ok but for offering constructive advice. I mocked them up for the last time just now with the new pushrods and ran the valves. The adjusters are all showing 1-1.5 threads on the bottom so I'm happy with my pushrod length. The retainers don't want to hit. Next is measuring them for side to side clearance and laying out shims before installation.
So I'll definitely get them all smooth with some sandpaper tootsie rolls when they come off this last time.
Bedtime for me gotta wake up and make the doughnuts!
Radar
Sleep well... for your next time reading... the sweep on the rocker/tip is what the engine SEES... your not perfect but its not bad... if you were to add lash caps thats the same as lowering the shaft and if you add the shims(they make a tapper shim that goes to zero on the upper edges which is the ONLY type of shim to use).. you raise the shaft up.. you dont need to spend money on something you can do with his kit... maybe I should build my own kit... it all comes back to the sweep and your ok.. again.. not perfect... I do my own stuff on this and my engine turns 8200 with econo W-2s.. its not magic like the guy is talking.. if he wants to sell his kit he should get a BETTER attitude to his customers... I do hope he does well with it
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: MR_P_BODY]
#1671979
09/20/14 03:29 PM
09/20/14 03:29 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,291 Tucson AZ,
MadMopars
pro stock
|
pro stock
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,291
Tucson AZ,
|
Quote:
Sleep well... for your next time reading... the sweep on the rocker/tip is what the engine SEES... your not perfect but its not bad... if you were to add lash caps thats the same as lowering the shaft and if you add the shims(they make a tapper shim that goes to zero on the upper edges which is the ONLY type of shim to use).. you raise the shaft up.. you dont need to spend money on something you can do with his kit... maybe I should build my own kit... it all comes back to the sweep and your ok.. again.. not perfect... I do my own stuff on this and my engine turns 8200 with econo W-2s.. its not magic like the guy is talking.. if he wants to sell his kit he should get a BETTER attitude to his customers... I do hope he does well with it
Mr. P, I would be interested to know what your opinion is on a couple things.
*Given the O.P "Interference" issues, what particular item in his valvetrain would you attribute this problem to? What item would you suggest be replaced to prevent this from happening?
*I really didn't think rocker arm manufacturers would recommend grinding on there parts to resolve the issue. I certainly can't imagine they will warranty the parts in the event of a failure. I guess I should call them before I hang my hat on that though.
*You mention both lowering and raising the shaft as well as valve lash caps. Obviuosly very different methods. In this particular application which would you have done and why?
*You mentioned building your own kit with tapered shims. I am curious to know how much the sweep would change with your preferred shims as opposed to the ones I just installed on my car from B3RE. I ask because my sweep is now 25% of what it was before. Substantial improvement in my opinion.
Obviously I have no "Performance based results to post yet, only measurements and pictures of what I understand to be improved / preferred geometry. In my application will Mike's kit equate to Performance gains? That has yet to be determined. It's also not to say that if it does not improve my performance that I don't have any other limiting factors to get past first. Regardless of what happens, I will be happy to share my experience.
Last thought and then I'm heading out to the garage for a bit. I have no doubt in my mind that B3RE could have corrected Radar's original problem with his kit and no grinding. The kit is posted for $120 bucks and EITHER WAY, the O.P needed push rods so that cost is a wash. I'm not saying that grinding the rocker arms didn't fix the problem and it very well may never be a problem. I'm just saying calling Mikes kit "Magic" is probably a bit out there.
If "Magic" is not using a grinder to make your rocker arms clear, prepare to be amazed.
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: MadMopars]
#1671981
09/20/14 09:53 PM
09/20/14 09:53 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972 Romeo MI
MR_P_BODY
Master
|
Master
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972
Romeo MI
|
Quote:
Quote:
Sleep well... for your next time reading... the sweep on the rocker/tip is what the engine SEES... your not perfect but its not bad... if you were to add lash caps thats the same as lowering the shaft and if you add the shims(they make a tapper shim that goes to zero on the upper edges which is the ONLY type of shim to use).. you raise the shaft up.. you dont need to spend money on something you can do with his kit... maybe I should build my own kit... it all comes back to the sweep and your ok.. again.. not perfect... I do my own stuff on this and my engine turns 8200 with econo W-2s.. its not magic like the guy is talking.. if he wants to sell his kit he should get a BETTER attitude to his customers... I do hope he does well with it
Mr. P, I would be interested to know what your opinion is on a couple things.
*Given the O.P "Interference" issues, what particular item in his valvetrain would you attribute this problem to? What item would you suggest be replaced to prevent this from happening?
*I really didn't think rocker arm manufacturers would recommend grinding on there parts to resolve the issue. I certainly can't imagine they will warranty the parts in the event of a failure. I guess I should call them before I hang my hat on that though.
*You mention both lowering and raising the shaft as well as valve lash caps. Obviuosly very different methods. In this particular application which would you have done and why?
*You mentioned building your own kit with tapered shims. I am curious to know how much the sweep would change with your preferred shims as opposed to the ones I just installed on my car from B3RE. I ask because my sweep is now 25% of what it was before. Substantial improvement in my opinion.
Obviously I have no "Performance based results to post yet, only measurements and pictures of what I understand to be improved / preferred geometry. In my application will Mike's kit equate to Performance gains? That has yet to be determined. It's also not to say that if it does not improve my performance that I don't have any other limiting factors to get past first. Regardless of what happens, I will be happy to share my experience.
Last thought and then I'm heading out to the garage for a bit. I have no doubt in my mind that B3RE could have corrected Radar's original problem with his kit and no grinding. The kit is posted for $120 bucks and EITHER WAY, the O.P needed push rods so that cost is a wash. I'm not saying that grinding the rocker arms didn't fix the problem and it very well may never be a problem. I'm just saying calling Mikes kit "Magic" is probably a bit out there.
If "Magic" is not using a grinder to make your rocker arms clear, prepare to be amazed.
I f I recall the OP needed to go lower on the shaft but instead of milling the shaft mount areas he could add a lash cap which does the same thing (the shaft is lower in relation to the valve tip).. on the shims.. they arent mine... they make 2 sizes if I recall. a .015 and a .030.. they might make .060... they are that thick at the bottom then tapper out to zero as they roll up the wall so your not applying the side load on the pedistals... on the rockers.. no you shouldnt need to grind them but its even suggested in the mopar book... but the springs are to large in diameter along with the retainers
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: AndyF]
#1671983
09/21/14 04:18 PM
09/21/14 04:18 PM
|
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,277 West Coast, USA
jbc426
master
|
master
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,277
West Coast, USA
|
AndyF: Now, that's a pretty picture!
1970 Plymouth 'Cuda #'s 440-6(block in storage)currently 493" 6 pack, Shaker, 5 speed Passon, 4.10's 1968 Plymouth Barracuda Convertible 408 Magnum EFI with 4 speed automatic overdrive, 3800 stall lock-up converter and 4.30's (closest thing to an automatic 5 speed going)
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: AndyF]
#1671985
09/21/14 05:51 PM
09/21/14 05:51 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972 Romeo MI
MR_P_BODY
Master
|
Master
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972
Romeo MI
|
Quote:
Yes, beehives are the very best solution. They are smaller and lighter than the regular springs so you get a performance improvement plus they eliminate the rocker arm clearance issue. But if there isn't any room in the budget there isn't any room. We used beehives on the 427 inch small block for Tim's road race Valiant. That setup worked really nice.
I'm sure that pic was to show Andys lift tool.. but looking at the roller axle centerline it sure looks like its well past the centerline of the valve stem but it might just be a angle thing in the pic
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: dirtybee]
#1671988
09/21/14 07:31 PM
09/21/14 07:31 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 31,023 Oregon
AndyF
I Win
|
I Win
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 31,023
Oregon
|
Quote:
All of Andy Fs pictures are pretty
Digital SLR + good light + tripod = good picture. I had a pro teach me some tricks so I could shoot the pictures for my book. The most important trick was to use a tripod. With a tripod you can slow the shutter speed way down. With a slow shutter then you don't need a flash. The flash usually ruins the picture when you're shooting car parts since the shiny surfaces reflect the flash.
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: AndyF]
#1671989
09/21/14 07:43 PM
09/21/14 07:43 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,467 So Cal
autoxcuda
Too Many Posts
|
Too Many Posts
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,467
So Cal
|
Quote:
I test fit Comps, PRW and RAS rocker arms on that engine. The Comps worked the best. They all fit with beehive springs, I think the RAS arms would've worked with standard springs but I don't recall.
...
I have the Comps with my E-brock heads and standard as delivered valve springs.
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: AndyF]
#1671990
09/21/14 08:00 PM
09/21/14 08:00 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972 Romeo MI
MR_P_BODY
Master
|
Master
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 52,972
Romeo MI
|
Quote:
I test fit Comps, PRW and RAS rocker arms on that engine. The Comps worked the best. They all fit with beehive springs, I think the RAS arms would've worked with standard springs but I don't recall.
Most people aren't able to test fit multiple rocker arms on an engine but I've found that with Mopars it is the best way to go. The various rocker arms all fit very differently. They are not interchangeable regardless of what people say.
Yeah that is nice to have various sets laying around the shop to test fit ... I have 2 sets in the shop to use.. T&D and the MP/Crane blues.. all the engine I have right now have T&D on them.. but I do have both the multi shaft and single shaft T&D to try.. but I would have to mill the stands off the W-2s if I wanted to run the multi shaft T&Ds if the single shaft ones didnt fit right... the only set of heads I have that dont have rockers on them is a set of standard length W-2 that are new but I did port them already
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: radar]
#1671991
09/21/14 08:29 PM
09/21/14 08:29 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,591 Canton, Ohio
Sport440
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,591
Canton, Ohio
|
Quote:
Geez I only took like .035 out of it in the deepest spot, which is where the witness marks were, then smoothed out the notch a little.
Should I call Larry Shepard to come get in line for head smacks?
He seemed to grind the bs out of those 273 rockers in his 'how to hot rod small block mopar engines' book! The builds on moparts all seem to run .6"+ lift cams though so if that's your point of reference I get it.
Btw this is all in good fun for me I am having a ball and always learn more with each engine I build or part I upgrade.
These style Rockers are way different in design then what you have. They have a much Wider base for strength then your type rockers.
But in all Fairness, you really didn't take that much off, and your working pressures aren't that high. As I said in my first post , you will probably be fine. Your Magnified pics, make it look worse then it probably is.
As you know by now from all of the other posts, there are better ways to get the clearance that you needed without grinding the rockers.
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: autoxcuda]
#1671992
09/21/14 09:37 PM
09/21/14 09:37 PM
|
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,682 Philadelphia
radar
OP
top fuel
|
OP
top fuel
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 1,682
Philadelphia
|
Quote:
Quote:
I test fit Comps, PRW and RAS rocker arms on that engine. The Comps worked the best. They all fit with beehive springs, I think the RAS arms would've worked with standard springs but I don't recall.
...
I have the Comps with my E-brock heads and standard as delivered valve springs.
The original springs and retainers ootb were on there with these same prw rockers for around seven years with only a couple incidents of an adjuster coming loose. There were no clearance issues with the prw rockers and the stock edelbrock spring set up.
On the other hand the motor wouldn't make any more power after 5000rpm or so with a comp xe275hl or an MP 557 cam and an airgap I don't know if the springs were too soft to keep the valves from floating or if the valvejob and ports were not up to flowing the air. It dynoed at 350/400 rwhp/tq so the eddy heads were getting the job done for a hot stock replacement at around 1hp/cid.
I'm getting real close to driving this motor. It seems like time is going slowly and money is going quickly- I broke my eagle crank in two pieces in June after around seven years of beating on it. I probably have the marginal traction of my 275/60 bfg tires to thank for not breaking more stuff!
|
|
|
Re: I could use advice to help set up my valvetrain
[Re: radar]
#1671993
09/21/14 10:44 PM
09/21/14 10:44 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 5,183
Porter67
master
|
master
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 5,183
|
Good job on the fitment. Im really really amazed you got them to work as I think I had a set of those rockers and they just cleared a stock 318 head. You might of gotten close with lash caps which some use for there own reasons and your keepers look like they are setup for the use of lash caps. But that's an added expense as well even if only $40 or so. I also have had good luck with the comp pro mags but am trying to fit HS currently as Ive got the older pro mag comps with near #420 open and a semi high spring rate of #431 (comp 977s) but could buzz the MP.557 to a 7400 chip on a 420 inch build, now the jump to a .640 lift lets me get by with the same spring setup. Before anyone says its too much spring pressure its because I use non conventional type solids. But I did eat a .557 due to the poor quality of the core itself. Rader to me it looks like your shafts are walking a bit, what are you using on your rocker shafts. I have several sets of the better then stock MP thick rocker clamps your welcome to a set if you want them. And if your not using studs you can use 1/4 longer bolts the oem heads. I shouldn't of been so harsh on the rocker arm guy but the small block eddies have been around long enough that many know what will work and what wont. For the fella who chastised me for that I have a set of indy cut to fit pushrods I was going to offer up but oddly the cups are for non oiling but the rods have oiling holes on the ball end. I don't know if indy messed up when they bagged them or if they are all like that.
|
|
|
|
|