Honestly, I don't like either. BUT, those aluminum mags aren't the worst I've ever seen. But it's kinda like putting Cragars on a Model T. Sure, you can do it.... but.... do you want to? I'm not a big fan of steelies, either. On the right car, maybe - but generally, no.

Your Charger would look great with some 15" Rallyes, maybe widened in the back a little. Or Keystones, or Slots, or Cragars.... anything to give it that 1970's flair. Modern wheels on a 50 year old car are like my Cragars on a model T comment.

I understand why you do it though: better tire selection, new wheels are actually round.... for practicality reasons.... I get it.