Duffman, I think we can both agree that whatever he chooses he is going to have good performance and be comfortable. I bought a '12 charger rt MAX, felt like sitting on a sofa and had every single option except the Beats byDre stereo upgrade. Heated/cooled seats, steering wheel, mirrors, heated/cooled cup holders, 8.4 screen, 20" chrome wheels, back up cam, ect. The only real difference I saw when shopping around ( looked at both models throughout the year range) the 300 had simulated wood trim if ordered so. I preferred the looks of the 2011 up model years on both. Opinions will vary. Good luck in finding one you like. If you live in an area that gets a decent amount of snow, think about awd models or buying snow tires.