This is what the recall wheel looks like in a 67 GTX. (in this pic it is wearing a Dodge center) The pic you have looks like the same wheel, except that the centers of the spokes are filled in with those padded things. Perhaps that is the Charger version?
It is my understanding that the reason for the recall is that in a crash, the drivers chest breaks the spokes, and they become like knives and can easliy puncture the lungs. I have also heard the finger thing, but have never had a problem with it. I have one on my 67 GTX. I have no proof, but I suspect it is original since the GTX is a 30,000 mile unmolested car. I picked up another one last year for an upcoming project.