Yeah we need to confirm that your getting fire to the ECU/coil in start (ign2)when the sw itself is turned to "start" otherwise I'd hate to see the pickup get R&R'd & that not b it esp as there may b a sw/wiring prob since in addition it wont energise the starter relay. If you're wanting to fire it up/break it in ASAP then yes R&R the pickup if it's bad/jump start it at the relay as not likely the "start" side wiring AND the pickup are BOTH bad