Let the man make up his own mind. He wants a Charger, so lets help him out.
I'll admit that when the 2006 Came out I was disappointed in the 4 door style. I own a 70 Charger and saw a 4 door as a sacrilege. Over time the design grew on me, and with the LX Challenger joining the group, I have gained an appreciation for the LX Charger. Good luck and welcome back.