I did the dash on my Demon and it was a perfect match. Half of my paint had peeled off. I used Tamiya for plastics, TS-1 red brown. Find at any decent hobby shop.

If you want to do it right, remove the cluster, steel-wool as much of the flaking paint as possible. Mask everything off, don't worry about covering the white-lettered call-outs. Two or three light coats of the red brown should do. Take some Liquid Paper or Bic brand white-out tape (this has all but replaced the brush-on white-out in offices) and place it over the call-outs. Use a small flat head screwdriver to rub the tape over the letters. You may have to do it again in localized spots. Clean up any "over rubbing" with an x-acto knive (or similiar), careful not to scrape any paint off while removing excess white.

Take your time and you will find the results rather satisfying!