If an NOS part has no shelf wear, should be a match to the other NOS moldings.
Not gonna fall out of a local tree, though.
Sending the 3 from one side out for refinishing should result in a perfect match, or send one with the offending part so the polisher/anodizer has a reference.
It would be a special person who can compare both sides at the same time if a proper job is done.
Either way, might be wise to avoid the Hemi Surcharge...