I’ve installed the Legendary oem stuff before and it looks pretty good. Get them to send you a sample before you decide. Me, I’d leave it alone. Patching would be hard to do. The old headliner is not that supple anymore and it would rip trying to go back in. I’ve got a small rip about an inch long in my oem AAR Cuda but I’m leaving it alone. I don’t have a cool story to go with mine either. Lol!