Didn't really get an answer to your question.
I did. Others have stated that there are differences with the alternatives but nothing you can see with the cap and trim ring installed. I still may go the Tony's route but I have to think about it. Again, thanks for the thoughts.
Jeff why not go used and save even more money?
I have two 15x7 wheels part number 4117054 that probably came on a 79 van or something.
I fitted the trim ring and center cap - they fit perfect. Once the trim ring is on you can't tell.
It would cost more in shipping then what I would want for the rims. You just need too find two more