I can't speak for the auto, but I've had my 5-speed '04 R/T since new and I still enjoy the car. I've replaced the struts, lower control arms, brake pads, timing belt, water pump, battery, and muffler. Water pump and timing belt were preventative maintenance. I also replaced the headlights when they became too hazy. While living overseas, I daily drove an employer-provided '12 Honda Civic for a few years and I can honestly say that the '04 Neon was a better car in every way except trunk space.