Diggin' that truck, Wyle E!

I'm in a similar situation on my '84, in my case the grille had been replaced by the original owner with a square tube grille.

I've been searching for a few months, but all of the junkyard stuff seems to be pretty much used up.

I've decided to hunt down a nice aluminum surround and lower reveal panel from an '86-'90, since someone is repopping the headlight surround/marker lights and grilles and they are VERY reasonable.

86-90 89 88 87 DODGE D150 PICKUP GRILLE HEADLIGHT BEZEL

A matching core support can be swapped in, or the headlight buckets can be moved slightly on the old core support to line up with the new headlight locations. I'll probably go ahead and swap the bumper brackets as well, and get a new repop '86-'90 bumper.