Just an FYI on the door weather-strips we do sell the glue on ones still - http://www.dodgeconnection.com/catalog/item/6756240/5555222.htm

I have heard the same problems with them as well though - I would say maybe 1 in 100 customers have ended up having the "too tight" issue you are experiencing with both types of seals.

Nice acquisition by the way - congrats!