Check out restorationspecialties.com with a sample of what you have and see if you can match something up. They have lots of profiles dating back to the 1920s, and the people there know their stuff.
I'm with you 100% on this one. Working on a 66 coronet wagon tailgate. Have it all apart. They had ALL the seals, knew what they were just based on the pics that I sent to them. Really knew their stuff. They also had ALL of the trim clips, etc and for reasonable money. Their online catalog is rough to even use, but when you call them, they seem to really have a handle on stuff