new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
#32688
12/13/06 06:13 PM
12/13/06 06:13 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
hotroddave40 originally told us about the use of GM V-6 springs, which he said are a drop on, no machining required. I've been doing a little investigating. first of all, the specs I found on rockauto is this: <a href="Sealed Power VS-1642 spring specs" target="_blank">http://info.rockauto.com/SealedPower/VS1642.html</a> if you do the math, this yields a spring rate of 365 lb/in. backsolving for the free length yields a 1.898" free length based on these specs. NapaOnline lists the free length as 1.94". the Sealed Power VS1642 cross references to every GM 3100, pushrod 3400, and pushrod 3500 V-6 from 1993 to present. armed with this info, I went out and yanked a few (and the retainers) from a '94 grand am in a local junkyard. I have a friend where I used to work that runs the test lab there. he did some testing for me to verify the sealed power specs. his findings on the sample I gave him: Free Length: 1.875" Travel before coil bind: .81" Coil Bind Height: 1.065" Spring Rate: 330lb/in sounds like a definite possibility, the calculated spring rate was slightly higher than the comp 901's I have on my LA headed 360 now, the measured (12 year old spring) was slightly lower. but the measured used spring had a higher spring rate than all the comp cams beehives (pn 26995 looks to be essentially a "drop on" spring for a magnum head), albeit the GM spring is a little light on seat pressure, which could be adjusted with shims at the expense of lift capability. it would be interesting to get my hands on a MP R/T spring to do a comparison test, since MP give absolutely 0 specs on that and now the the cheap part: the GM part numbers for these components are 10166343 for the valvesprings, and 10166344 for the retainers. if you go to the site www.gmpartsdirect.com and type those numbers in, you'll find the springs are $4.71 each, and the retainers are $1.52 each, compared to the manciniracing.com price for the MP .525" springs and retainers at $9.50 each fo the springs, and $8.95 each for the retainers. so you can get brand new retainers and beehive springs for ~$125 to your door (gmpartsdirect estimates the shipping at ~$27!) attached is the force curve from the instron he tested the springs on. this weekend I will install a set on the magnum heads I have under the workbench and take pics for all to see. I'll also do my best to measure the current installed height of the stock springs vs. the installed height of these springs (using the 3100 retainers) in case of any changes there, so stay tuned.
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: dmerc]
#32691
12/13/06 11:04 PM
12/13/06 11:04 PM
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,828 houston texas
gremlinsteve
top fuel
|
top fuel
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,828
houston texas
|
have you given thought to a gm z06 spring?
steve
if You Like Gremlinsteve. Gremlinsteve Likes You.
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: gremlinsteve]
#32693
12/14/06 10:14 AM
12/14/06 10:14 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
Quote:
have you given thought to a gm z06 spring?
steve
yup, in fact the 3100 retainer is the same as an LS1/LS6 retainer, they offer a little more seat pressure, and up to .6" lift capability....but, the LS1/6 springs are 1.8" IH, and a smaller lower ID, so some machining will be required on the head to fit them. the V-6 springs should be a drop on, no machining required for those on a budget and can't/don't want to afford $100-$150 in machining, and have moderate lift cams (in the ~.5" and under lift range)...LS6 springs are 315lb/in w/105lb seat pressure installed at 1.8".
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32694
12/14/06 01:16 PM
12/14/06 01:16 PM
|
Anonymous
Unregistered
|
Anonymous
Unregistered
|
Thanks Patrick! Good job, I was waiting for this info for a while. I'll tune in to see how the installation worked.
Ran
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
#32695
12/21/06 02:12 PM
12/21/06 02:12 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
Update:
well, I finally made it out to the garage to do some measuring, etc. and take some pics. pics will get up here in the next few days.
the GM springs do fit as a drop on. on my particular set of heads, they are quite snug around the "pilot" area. that's the good news.
here's the (arguably) not so good news. the closest I could measure my installed height on my stock, looks to be original valve job heads, was 1.625" (1 5/8"). the 3.1L retainers actually reduced installed height by around 1/32" (to ~1.593" IH) using the mag keepers. using the 3.1L keepers, it increased IH to about 1.65", BUT, the tip of the valve was below the retainer, and the rockers hit the retainer first. if you've got a cam that's ~.45" lift or less with 1.5's, you should be ok with these springs as is.
for my project, using these springs, since I have a .462/.470 cam (will be .493/.501 with the mag rockers) I want to see my installed height to be at least 1.63", since these springs coil bind at about 1.065". that means
1) either the spring pad would need to be machined down ~1/32-1/16" to get adequate installed height, or 2) the valve will need to be sunk in about that amount with the valve job.
a bit of a bummer, but since the heads need a valve job anyway, it shouldn't be any added expense to sink the valves in 1/16", not like machining the spring pockets, which would be an additional operation, and an additional charge.
I wonder what effect sinking the valve into the head has for flow...
again, YMMV, et al.
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32696
12/21/06 02:23 PM
12/21/06 02:23 PM
|
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,848 Memphis
HemiRick
master
|
master
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,848
Memphis
|
Sinking the valves almost always has a bad effect on flow.
Take care, Rick 68 Coronet R/T 440 & 68 Charger 528 Hemi,and 5 Challengers! 6 cyl, 318, 360, 383, 451
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: ZIPPY]
#32698
12/21/06 03:31 PM
12/21/06 03:31 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,820 near Alexandria, VA
Gas_Bandit
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 4,820
near Alexandria, VA
|
Sounds like way too much effort to only be able to use a cam not worth using with the better magnum heads anyway.
2003 Mercury Marauder, 34k miles, 3.73s and custom flash tuned 1981 Camaro, 350 w/ Holley Stealth Ram MPEFI, Sportsman heads, roller cam, self-burned chips, wideband O2 1983 Firebird TA 1993 Saturn SL2 83k
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: Gas_Bandit]
#32699
12/21/06 03:40 PM
12/21/06 03:40 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 7,131 Amarillo, Texas
BBR
master
|
master
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 7,131
Amarillo, Texas
|
Patrick, will a lash cap fit with the GM keepers and Mag retainer? If I were doing a set of mag heads that probably could stand to have a new VJ, I'd go with the more readily available 11/32 valves. There's a billion different valve lengths/springs/locks/retainers to choose from if you do that.
Drag Week 2011 - 77th place - DD Drag Week 2012 - 2nd place SRBB N/A Drag Week 2014 - Kapooya RMRW 2018 RMRW 2020
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: ZIPPY]
#32700
12/21/06 05:56 PM
12/21/06 05:56 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
Quote:
If I was building one (which I might, sometime in '07), I would probably just use the MP .600 lift springs which Mancini shows at 7.99, right between the cost of the two listed.
Not sure why a drop in spring would be advertised for .600 lift, when retainer to guide interferance will come into play well before that. I guess that is a roundabout way of saying the guides will have to be cut down which is no biggie.
yeah, and frankly there isn't enough install height IMHO to get .6" lift without getting into spring breakage problems....biggest kicker with the MP springs are if all the 2.2's have been crushed out of yards around you. the retainers are like $9 ea (vs. $1.50 ea for the GM/LS1) for the MP number....
I wonder how much you can machine out of the spring pocket to get more IH?
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: BBR]
#32701
12/21/06 05:57 PM
12/21/06 05:57 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
Quote:
Patrick, will a lash cap fit with the GM keepers and Mag retainer?
If I were doing a set of mag heads that probably could stand to have a new VJ, I'd go with the more readily available 11/32 valves. There's a billion different valve lengths/springs/locks/retainers to choose from if you do that.
don't know. probably not. the keepers are flush with the top of the valve.
yeah, that's what I'm thinking--if you're doing a serious mag head, long chevy 1.94 valves are probably the way to go.
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32703
12/22/06 07:39 PM
12/22/06 07:39 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 12,478 Kalispell Mt.
HotRodDave
I Live Here
|
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 12,478
Kalispell Mt.
|
Could you give us a side by side comparison with the stock mag info?
I am not causing global warming, I am just trying to hold off a impending Ice Age!
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: HotRodDave]
#32704
12/23/06 08:55 AM
12/23/06 08:55 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
I'll try get one of the stock mag springs tested for spring rate and coil bind height. according to the info sheet for them sealed power replacements, the OEM mags calculate out a spring rate of ~240lb/in. It probably won't happen before new years, though.
anyhoo, here are some pictures. **WARNING, THEY'RE BIG** and darn, they show off every detail of how dirty these heads are from being yanked of a motor and sitting under a bench for a year....
The GM springs/retainers and the springs retainers on my mags (I'm assuming they're stock) are shown side by side. Magnum on the left, GM V-6 on the right for all pics.
hotroddave- do these pics parallel what you saw with these springs?
Last edited by patrick; 12/23/06 09:25 AM.
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32705
12/23/06 08:57 AM
12/23/06 08:57 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
another one, side by side. you can see how much more of a beehive the GM spring is--the retainer is much smaller.
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32706
12/23/06 09:06 AM
12/23/06 09:06 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
side by side assembled on the head
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
Re: new cheap magnum spring upgrade for moderate cams
[Re: patrick]
#32707
12/23/06 09:08 AM
12/23/06 09:08 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123 Grand Haven, MI
patrick
OP
I Live Here
|
OP
I Live Here
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,123
Grand Haven, MI
|
side shot, showing stock rocker on the GM sprung valve. bolt is simulating the pushrod
1976 Spinnaker White Plymouth Duster, /6 A833OD 1986 Silver/Twilight Blue Chrysler 5th Ave HotRod **SOLD!*** 2011 Toxic Orange Dodge Charger R/T 2017 Grand Cherokee Overland 2014 Jeep Cherokee Latitude (holy crap, my daughter is driving)
|
|
|
|
|