Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
ballast resistor question? #1334551
11/13/12 02:32 AM
11/13/12 02:32 AM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
J
Jeff_383 Offline OP
super stock
Jeff_383  Offline OP
super stock
J

Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
I've got and MP distributor and a chrome box with a 45 year old stock 318 coil (not on a 318 though). I bought a Petronix flamethrower, with 1.5 ohms, resistance coil. Do I still need the ballast? Or can that coil see 12 volts all the time? I thought I've read that the ECU doesn't like 12 all the time either. I'm really clueless here.

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334552
11/13/12 02:42 AM
11/13/12 02:42 AM
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,798
Castlegar, BC, Canada
That AMC Guy Offline
master
That AMC Guy  Offline
master

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,798
Castlegar, BC, Canada
Pertronix coils have internal resistance and do not need a ballast. That much I know.


Bloody Mary, Full of Vodka, Blessed art thou among cocktails....

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: That AMC Guy] #1334553
11/13/12 05:49 AM
11/13/12 05:49 AM
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 208
Norrland, Sweden
Swedcharger67 Offline
enthusiast
Swedcharger67  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 208
Norrland, Sweden
Quote:

Pertronix coils have internal resistance and do not need a ballast. That much I know.



I'm afraid this is a misunderstanding.

All coils have internal resistance, and no coils that I am aware of have ballast resistors built in, especially not the Pertronix coils.

To have a high performance ignition system, i.e. lots of energy in the spark (not talking voltage, that is different from energy), you need a BIG current to charge the coil between ignition pulses. To get a BIG current thru the primary winding of the coil the resistance needs to be very low, like 0.3 Ohm.

With 14V and 0.3 Ohm the current is 47 Amp, and the power dissipation (heat generated) is 653 Watt (10 pcs of H4 halogen bulbs), if the ignition remains in "on" and the engine is not running. With 1.5 Ohm you have 9.3 Amp and 131 Watt.

With modern electronics it's quite easy to limit the current to safe levels, to protect the coil and the electronics itself. This is why for example the Pertronix Ignitor 3 and the FlameThrower 3 coil (0.3 Ohm) dont't go up in smoke when switched on. The Ignitor 3 is limiting the current to safe levels, no ballast resistor used.
Other systems not using ballast resistors do it the same way with current limiter built into the electronix.

This is why you can't take a "stupid" ignition box and hook it up a high performance/high current coil without a ballast resistor...the stupid box doesn't know how to limit the current to the high performance coil and it will burn itself and/or the coil to ashes...

That it's wasted money to buy a high performance coil, and then decrease and limit the performance of the coil with a ballast resistor...that's another story...


Martin, 67 Charger, 512 cui, E85, MegaSquirt MS3X sequential ignition & injection
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334554
11/13/12 10:33 AM
11/13/12 10:33 AM
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 15,487
Florida
S
scratchnfotraction Offline
I Live Here
scratchnfotraction  Offline
I Live Here
S

Joined: May 2003
Posts: 15,487
Florida
Quote:

I've got and MP distributor and a chrome box with a 45 year old stock 318 coil (not on a 318 though). I bought a Petronix flamethrower, with 1.5 ohms, resistance coil. Do I still need the ballast? Or can that coil see 12 volts all the time? I thought I've read that the ECU doesn't like 12 all the time either. I'm really clueless here.




I run a pertronix points conversion with a chrome 40,000 volt flamethrower coil.

I have had the BR by-passed for 15 yrs on the 85-318 truck with no trouble from it or the conversion unit in the dist.

on my other truck,I ditched the ecu/MP dist/BR by swaping in a points dist with the pertronix points conversion,flamethorwer coil. upluged and taped up the ecu plug and hide it behind the fender brace.(2yrs on the 440 truck so far)

I will be running a mallory duel point mech dist with a pertronix points conversion with the flamethrower coil with BR by-passed also.

I am not sure if adding the flamethrower coil to a ecu/MP elect dist system would still need the BR. I would think it is ok as it is made for a full 12 volts with the pertronix points conversions.

how long the ecu holds up like mentioned above is another ?

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334555
11/13/12 11:10 AM
11/13/12 11:10 AM
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,041
Lincoln Nebraska
R
RapidRobert Offline
Circle Track
RapidRobert  Offline
Circle Track
R

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,041
Lincoln Nebraska
The Pertronix coils are made for full 12V so the coil will be fine and with 1.5 ohms I believe the ECU can switch on/off the amount of primary current that you'll have with 1.5 ohms resistance. I'm running an FBO coil with a MP .25 ohm ballast triggered by an OEM ECU & it starts instantly/runs flawless & iirc the (measured) pri ohms of my FBO coil was .8 ohms so I'm passing more primary current on my setup than you would be plus you're running a hotter box than I am but with that being said it's always a good idea to carry spares in the glove box . EDIT I was thinking that OE points coils like your 45 year old one had 1.5 ohms & later electronic ones had .5 ohms but I may be backwards on that & the actual ohms will likely be somewhat different than the nominal listed ohm spec

Last edited by RapidRobert; 11/13/12 11:31 AM.

live every 24 hour block of time like it's your last day on earth
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: RapidRobert] #1334556
11/13/12 02:03 PM
11/13/12 02:03 PM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
J
Jeff_383 Offline OP
super stock
Jeff_383  Offline OP
super stock
J

Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
Well, then could I take apart the resistor and put an 8 or 10 ga wire in place of the resistor itself and reinstall it for appearance?

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334557
11/13/12 03:11 PM
11/13/12 03:11 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
68LAR Offline
master
68LAR  Offline
master

Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
Just my .
Mopar production has a 1 ohm resistor that I believe will work just fine with the chrome box and the flame thrower. Part number 5206436.


4 speed street legal. Best time 10.99 @ 124 mph on 93 octane pump gas @ 3926# total weight
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334558
11/13/12 03:43 PM
11/13/12 03:43 PM
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 15,487
Florida
S
scratchnfotraction Offline
I Live Here
scratchnfotraction  Offline
I Live Here
S

Joined: May 2003
Posts: 15,487
Florida
Quote:

Well, then could I take apart the resistor and put an 8 or 10 ga wire in place of the resistor itself and reinstall it for appearance?




yes,I used a #10 strand automotive wire.

I gut the BR shell and re-use the male spade ends from it,then solder them to the #10 wire,fit it inside the BR shell and mount to firewall.


Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: scratchnfotraction] #1334559
11/15/12 03:31 PM
11/15/12 03:31 PM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
J
Jeff_383 Offline OP
super stock
Jeff_383  Offline OP
super stock
J

Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
If the coil can take 12 volts, but the ECU can't, could I then just bypass the ballast for the coil but leave it wired over to the ECU? Or does power go from the coil to the ECU too? I'm just trying to learn here.

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334560
11/15/12 04:33 PM
11/15/12 04:33 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
68LAR Offline
master
68LAR  Offline
master

Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
Quote:

If the coil can take 12 volts, but the ECU can't, could I then just bypass the ballast for the coil but leave it wired over to the ECU? Or does power go from the coil to the ECU too? I'm just trying to learn here.



The ballast resistor is there for the coil. If Pertronix comes with a 1.5 ohm resistor with the coil, then I would think it is needed. I would not think that the coil will handle a full 12volts +. The exception would be if used with an ignition system such as MSD where the resistance is built into the unit.


4 speed street legal. Best time 10.99 @ 124 mph on 93 octane pump gas @ 3926# total weight
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: 68LAR] #1334561
11/15/12 04:39 PM
11/15/12 04:39 PM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
J
Jeff_383 Offline OP
super stock
Jeff_383  Offline OP
super stock
J

Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
The petronix does not come with a external resisitor. It is built with 1.5 ohms of resisitance in it. It is designed for a full 12 volts.

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334562
11/15/12 04:55 PM
11/15/12 04:55 PM
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,041
Lincoln Nebraska
R
RapidRobert Offline
Circle Track
RapidRobert  Offline
Circle Track
R

Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 36,041
Lincoln Nebraska
Quote:

If the coil can take 12 volts, but the ECU can't,


All ECU's take full 12V (or higher as the charging voltage will be above that), only the coils use a ballast to reduce it & as said some coils take full 12V (no ballast). The blue wire (ign1) run circuit has switched 12V & it goes straight to the ECU and T's off as a parallel circuit to the ballast & thru it to the coil, so the ECU gets full and the coil gets less if that helps


live every 24 hour block of time like it's your last day on earth
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334563
11/15/12 04:55 PM
11/15/12 04:55 PM
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
68LAR Offline
master
68LAR  Offline
master

Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 4,013
South Park, Pa.
If that's true then I would think that you could run a full 12 volts to the coil and by-pass the ballast all together. I'd run the engine for a while and periodically check the coil for excessive heat. If it doesn't get HOT then you should be "good to go".


4 speed street legal. Best time 10.99 @ 124 mph on 93 octane pump gas @ 3926# total weight
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334564
11/15/12 07:48 PM
11/15/12 07:48 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,445
So Cal
Sinitro Offline
master
Sinitro  Offline
master

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,445
So Cal
Many people do not understand the task of the ballast resistor..
Certain newer coils do not require a ballast resistor, they either have it built-in or are designed to handle the higher input voltage. The purpose of the ballast resistor is to protect the coil from higher current rather than voltage as the resistor heats up its resistance increases which decreases the current to the coil..

Just my $0.02....

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Sinitro] #1334565
11/15/12 08:18 PM
11/15/12 08:18 PM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
J
Jeff_383 Offline OP
super stock
Jeff_383  Offline OP
super stock
J

Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 877
Pittsburgh, Pa
Well then, is there even a benefit to not run the resistor to the coil?

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Jeff_383] #1334566
11/16/12 01:29 AM
11/16/12 01:29 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,445
So Cal
Sinitro Offline
master
Sinitro  Offline
master

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,445
So Cal
Quote:

Well then, is there even a benefit to not run the resistor to the coil?




If...
The coil can handle 12V directly then delete the ballast resistor...
The coil is simply a voltage step-up transformer, the higher the input voltage the higher the output.. Be sure to adjust the plug gap considering the higher voltage..

Just my $0.02...

Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: Sinitro] #1334567
11/16/12 03:11 AM
11/16/12 03:11 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,421
Balt. Md
3
383man Offline
Too Many Posts
383man  Offline
Too Many Posts
3

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,421
Balt. Md
Not being smart but it seems a post like this comes up about once every few months and the poster gets many different answers that can really confuse them. I believe one of the Mopar mags about 6 months or so ago ran an article and said basically any Mopar electronic ign will work fine without using a ballast resister and told everyone to pretty much throw away your ballast if you have electronic ign meaning no points. At least thats the way I heard it. I know I started racing muscle cars in the early 70's and most still had points then. I also know I saw a few guys burn up the chrome MP ecu by using the wrong or no ballast or the wrong coil and I saw a few coils go bad. In fact MP had a section in their eng book on what ballast to use with the different ecu boxes they had out there in use. And to this day it still seems to confuse many.

Do I understand this right as the original poster here is using a MP ecu and bought a Petronix coil to use with it ?? I am guessing you are using a MP dist ? Honestly my best advice would be to either go on the Pertronix website or call their tech line and talk to them and tell them just what you have and see what they recomend since it is their coil and they designed it. No matter how much we tell you we are not the engineers who made it and if we tell you wrong you will be the one on the side of the road with a burnt up coil or ecu. Like I said I dont mean to sound like a smart a$$ as I can also tell you what I recomend but myself I have not used that coil ever on my cars.
Bottom line is the current will go thru the coil and thru the ecu to ground so the wrong current could damage either one. Your ecu will turn the primary circuit on and off but what ever current flows in the system (2 amps or 6 amps) will flow thru the coil and the ecu and can burn up either if its not right. If you use the wrong or no ballast you may burn the coil or ecu up. We can tell you to run no ballast or a .25 ballast or a 1.5 ballast. Many will work but you want the setup that will keep working and not damage any of the parts.

My advise of course is carry spares to be safe and call Petronix and get their advise. Ron

Last edited by 383man; 11/16/12 03:13 AM.
Re: ballast resistor question? [Re: 383man] #1334568
11/17/12 11:42 AM
11/17/12 11:42 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 166
MINNESOTA
B
BRONZEBEE Offline
member
BRONZEBEE  Offline
member
B

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 166
MINNESOTA
That resistor will save your ignition box from melting the epoxy from the back side of it,i know this for a fact!!This car was running and driving for years until....
Had a stumble above 5500 rpm removed ballast, stumble gone problem fixed.
Week later cruze night car quit,open hood black ooooz running down the fire wall.
Had a dizzy problem causing the stumble.Replaced the dizzy and the box,installed a new ballast.

Run the ballast resistor,it is there for a reason







Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1