Contacted the company, they wanted the part number off of the original box. Of course my luck the kids helped me clean up the shop 2 days earlier and it went out with the trash. I told them that sent them all the info I had and a couple pictures. Short version is either they sent me the wrong carpet or this is some of the worst fitting carpet I have ever seen.

I have it pulled as tight as I can around the seat area (in fact a little too tight on the driver's side creating a little gap along the tunnel) to try to get the extra out. You can see there is a lot of extra carpet around my shifter, right where the 4-speed hump would be.