Feel your pain Duster Dude. Am in the same situation with a Chally I aquired years ago thru a towing service I worked for. Ohio is a real P.I.T.A. to work with on titles. You tell the DMV the truth, and you hit a dead end, fabricate a tail of whooey and they'll reluctantly MAYBE issue a self-assembled title that looks screwy to a cop. Been pondering either Broadway or Getatitle.com. Some services even state in their adds that they will not under any cicumstances deal with Ohio or a half-dozen other states. Makes you realize they've had trouble also, and wonder what "Cure" the other guys have come up with. Or are you supplied with what you "Should need" in most states to get a title and when things don't work out you're left to haggle for your money back? Good luck and posts any results you come up with.
Fellow Buckeye