You can say the reproduction fenders are garbage, but most people are using them and are highly unlikely to spend the money on NOS fenders. The ones who are willing to spend the money on NOS fenders are not going to pay 5k a piece for them. $2500 to $3000 is the right number for them each depending upon condition and the amount of shelf wear on them.

70 Charger R/T SE 472 Hemi 70 Charger R/T convertible 70 Charger R/T V Code Sixpack 69 Charger R/T SE Sunroofcar 68 Charger 383 68 Charger 318 71 Charger R/T 70 Challenger convertible 71 Challenger convertible 71 Cuda 340 09 Challenger R/T Classic