Moparts

Help me identify this crankshaft

Posted By: chagjr

Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/16/20 11:55 PM

Hello all,

I have a Dart with a 440. I am installing a new transmission. I think the previous owner had a converter and flex plate for a cast crank 440. All of my new components are for a internal balanced steel crankshaft motor. I want to make sure the crankshaft is steel.
Can you tell from the rear flange. I am pretty sure this is a 1973 motor.
Maltese cross on engine identification pad.

Attached picture 53C77E48-A9F5-49E7-94EC-A268F00C8EC1.jpeg
Attached picture 13A9F1A8-B615-435F-86C9-D19867649760.jpeg
Posted By: fourgearsavoy

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:15 AM

Does it have the dampner for the cast crank? Did it vibrate badly before? What I'm getting at is if it was smooth before then you need the properly balanced converter that you took off twocents

Gus beer
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:15 AM

Here’s a photo of the balancer.
I am finding all sorts of things that are spooking me as I go through the car.
I just want a second set of eyes to verify. Everything says steel crank.

Attached picture A4DAAF0B-215A-4545-A702-4F1B63847E84.jpeg
Posted By: fourgearsavoy

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:21 AM

Did your converter or flexplate have weights on it? That looks like a forged crank dampner though shruggy also the crank not being drilled for a manual input also says later model forged or cast crank. Most of the 440 forged cranks I have used were at least rough drilled for a 4-speed pilot.

Gus beer
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:45 AM

It had a vibration that came in at about 3500 RPM. It had the round flex plate with the bite section, and the converter had 3 weights on it.
I was thinking this being a steel crank motor with these parts was the cause of my vibration.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 01:04 AM

Low mph cruising or heavy acceleration from a stop, no vibration. Interstate cruising around 60 mph vibration comes in.

My thinking is the previous owner assumed it was a late model 440 with a cast crank. Installed late model transmission, flex plate, and converter. My research before I started tranny swap, motor is a steel crank truck 440. I purchased TCI 727, with 2800 stall converter.
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 02:15 AM

Originally Posted by chagjr
It had a vibration that came in at about 3500 RPM. It had the round flex plate with the bite section, and the converter had 3 weights on it.
I was thinking this being a steel crank motor with these parts was the cause of my vibration.


There's your problem, if the convertor has weights on it it shouldn't have the flex plate with the "Bite" out of it, it should have one or the other, not both. If it's a forged crank there should be no large weights on the convertor and a completely round flex plate.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 02:47 AM

Thanks! That was good information.
So, with the vibration I described, could it just have been the converter?
Based on the photo information, do you think I have a forged crank 440?
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 02:52 AM

The harmonic balancer looks like a forged crank balancer but with the crank not drilled for a four speed it could be a cast crank. Only way to be sure is drop the oil pan and look at the crankshaft, that's what I'd do. That way there's no more guessing.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 03:02 AM

Okay, more work frown. The balancers should not be interchangeable if there is a concern. I will drain the oil and use a camera.
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 03:12 AM

If you find it's a forged crank that flex plate and weighted convertor would definitely cause an imbalance. And if you find it's a cast crank only use either the weighted convertor or the "bite" flex plate, not both.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 03:43 AM

Thank you!
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 05:16 AM

Look for the forging or casting number on the crankshaft and post that on here scope up
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 05:18 AM

Remove that after market flex plate and use a stock Mopar flexplate with a standard converter with no weights welded onto it twocents
Posted By: 6bblgt

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 07:21 AM

is there a partial VIN stamped on it? (mid-passenger side near the oil pan rail)
Posted By: Sniper

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:25 AM

Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
Originally Posted by chagjr
It had a vibration that came in at about 3500 RPM. It had the round flex plate with the bite section, and the converter had 3 weights on it.
I was thinking this being a steel crank motor with these parts was the cause of my vibration.


There's your problem, if the convertor has weights on it it shouldn't have the flex plate with the "Bite" out of it, it should have one or the other, not both. If it's a forged crank there should be no large weights on the convertor and a completely round flex plate.


Not so fast,

Converters have two types of weights on them. One set, usually on the side, balance the converter to neutral. If the converter is then to be used in an external balance engine then additional weights, usually on the front, are added for the imbalance. A pic would clarify this.

So just having three weights on it doesn't mean it's an external balance converter.

All that said, nothing external with confirm or deny it's a cast or forged crank. You will need to pull the pan. Look at the parting line on the crank, thin line cast crank, wide line forged crank.

Attached picture crankshaftid.jpg
Posted By: dvw

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 11:24 AM

Drain the oil. Use a $20 cell phone bore scope camera to look up at the crank parting line. Stick it thru the drain plug hole.
Doug
Posted By: fastmark

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:39 PM

I’ve bought lots of motors over the years and I’m not sure I have ever seen a steel crank with no hole at all. The steel shafts I have in my possession all have some kind of a hole, even if it is too small. I’ve even got some steel shafts out of trucks with pilot bushing installed but they had an auto from the factory. I have seen lots of cast cranks with no holes. That being said, never say never with Ma Mopar. If you have a round aftermarket flex plate with the round notch for the imbalance, you don’t need a converter with the imbalance as well. The three weights are probably just for the initial balance of the converter. I’ve got a picture on my phone of the big oem weight for a cast crank 440 I’ll post. I thinks it’s like 13 oz. My bud just bought a 69 charger 4 speed car. They had installed a cast crank motor with external balance and a neutral flywheel. It vibrated starting at 2000 rpm. There is no way to be sure in this situation until you look at the crank. Do you have a windage tray installed? It may be hard to see without pulling the pan. Someone could have taken a cast crank and had it internally balanced. Look for non factory holes or heavy metal in the crank throws. Honestly, you are just guessing unless you pull the pan. My best guess is that you have a externally balanced cast crank, a flex plate with the proper external balance already on and a neural converter. All this would match. If that is the case,the neutral balancer on the front needs to be changed to an external one to balance everything.

Attached picture C805124E-B35A-4178-B0DC-D28BB1AC4AF7.jpeg
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 12:57 PM

Originally Posted by Cab_Burge
Remove that after market flex plate and use a stock Mopar flexplate with a standard converter with no weights welded onto it twocents


That’s the plan up
Posted By: slantzilla

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 01:01 PM

Did it shake in neutral just revving the engine up?
Posted By: fastmark

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 05:09 PM

Originally Posted by chagjr
Originally Posted by Cab_Burge
Remove that after market flex plate and use a stock Mopar flexplate with a standard converter with no weights welded onto it twocents


That’s the plan up


Let’s us know the results.👍
Posted By: 6PakBee

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 05:25 PM

Before we get too far down the road, if your engine has a harmonic balancer like this, and a flexplate like this, it could be a heavy rod forged steel crank engine. This era was a real mish-mash with Mopar.

Attached picture 3512017 Harmonic Damper.jpg
Attached picture 1970 10238 Forged Crank Flexplate - 1.JPG
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:13 PM

Originally Posted by slantzilla
Did it shake in neutral just revving the engine up?


No.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:18 PM

It definitely has the 73 forged crank balancer.

Here is the converter and flex plate I removed.

Attached picture 897EC0B6-ED3D-4D54-B35F-CEA30E2BA4E5.jpeg
Attached picture 278D40EB-EC40-4E33-AF6B-D8299B2F305D.jpeg
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:20 PM

Here is a photo of the balancer again-

Attached picture 16509A87-23A6-4B45-B400-5638D17573E7.jpeg
Attached picture 51D09E69-E8E4-4AC8-9836-0F6889D9C74D.jpeg
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:27 PM

We need to see pics of the front of the convertor. The weights you pictured are to balance a neutral balance convertor, show the front, that's where an external balanced convertor will be balanced at.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:27 PM

Like I mentioned before, I am pretty sure this is forged crank motor that had a miss match transmission set up.
I am an enthusiast not a guru. I am making an educated guess hoping Moparts can massage out my uncertainty.
The vibration only occurred at around 60 mph. 391 rear.

Here are the new flex plate and converter.

Attached picture 857D5F64-84AB-46D9-BF3B-A31D4F448DC1.jpeg
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:34 PM

Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
We need to see pics of the front of the convertor. The weights you pictured are to balance a neutral balance convertor, show the front, that's where an external balanced convertor will be balanced at.


Here is the front, no weights. So it could have been just the flex plate causing the vibration?

Attached picture 8FC8BEC3-4154-4CDD-B936-4EB846C904DF.jpeg
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:38 PM

Okay, that's a neutral balance convertor, no weights on front but the bite flex plate is for using that convertor on a cast crank engine. If your engine is a forged crank engine that is the wrong flex plate for it. Use your new flex plate.
Posted By: John_Kunkel

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:45 PM

Originally Posted by fastmark
I’ve bought lots of motors over the years and I’m not sure I have ever seen a steel crank with no hole at all. The steel shafts I have in my possession all have some kind of a hole, even if it is too small.


iagree First pic with the shallow drill point cut looks like a cast crank.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 09:54 PM

Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
Okay, that's a neutral balance convertor, no weights on front but the bite flex plate is for using that convertor on a cast crank engine. If your engine is a forged crank engine that is the wrong flex plate for it. Use your new flex plate.
.

Thanks for all of the help. I have another question regarding the transmission I removed.
What did this come out of? This section was hitting the frame in the tunnel that the tranny cross member attaches to.
It kept the transmission down a little causing the steering linkage to hit the oil pan when making a right turn. The new transmission tail shaft housing is what I am used to seeing. It does not have that.

Attached picture image.jpg
Attached picture D989D60E-09E4-43F5-B378-BF93E1A05BA8.jpeg
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:00 PM

If you discover it IS a cast crank engine that convertor and bite flex plate is correct for it and someone has the wrong harmonic balancer on the engine.
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:07 PM

That's the snap ring access plate, you need a trans with that plate on the bottom by the trans mount or you could hammer the crossmember for fitment.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:09 PM

Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
If you discover it IS a cast crank engine that convertor and bite flex plate is correct for it and someone has the wrong harmonic balancer on the engine.


:(, cry, sawzall
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:14 PM

Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
That's the snap ring access plate, you need a trans with that plate on the bottom by the trans mount or you could hammer the crossmember for fitment.


I am ready to go.... new transmission in the box,

Attached picture image.jpg
Posted By: GODSCOUNTRY340

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:18 PM

GOOD, now you just need to find out if the crank's cast or forged before you put that trans in place.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:25 PM

Gods country 340, you have filled in the blanks for me.
Thanks so much for your help!

I should be ready to go when the current event of present time has passed.

👍😎

Attached picture 134FA2F2-2EC6-4988-AA8D-0296ABD7AD35.jpeg
Posted By: SNK-EYZ

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 10:36 PM

Originally Posted by chagjr
Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
Okay, that's a neutral balance convertor, no weights on front but the bite flex plate is for using that convertor on a cast crank engine. If your engine is a forged crank engine that is the wrong flex plate for it. Use your new flex plate.
.

Thanks for all of the help. I have another question regarding the transmission I removed.
What did this come out of? This section was hitting the frame in the tunnel that the tranny cross member attaches to.



It kept the transmission down a little causing the steering linkage to hit the oil pan when making a right turn.
The new transmission tail shaft housing is what I am used to seeing. It does not have that.


You said this is in a Dart (A-Body), what oil pan are you using?

A standard big block oil pan doesn't clear the center link/idler arm on a Dart, it has to have a recess in it or be reworked for clearance.
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/17/20 11:35 PM

Originally Posted by SNK-EYZ
Originally Posted by chagjr
Originally Posted by GODSCOUNTRY340
Okay, that's a neutral balance convertor, no weights on front but the bite flex plate is for using that convertor on a cast crank engine. If your engine is a forged crank engine that is the wrong flex plate for it. Use your new flex plate.
.

Thanks for all of the help. I have another question regarding the transmission I removed.
What did this come out of? This section was hitting the frame in the tunnel that the tranny cross member attaches to.



It kept the transmission down a little causing the steering linkage to hit the oil pan when making a right turn.
The new transmission tail shaft housing is what I am used to seeing. It does not have that.


You said this is in a Dart (A-Body), what oil pan are you using?

A standard big block oil pan doesn't clear the center link/idler arm on a Dart, it has to have a recess in it or be reworked for clearance.


I am pretty sure this is the correct pan.
The second photo shows where it was hitting. I have been sorting this car out for a year and a half. I hop to have all of the gremlins out soon.

Attached picture E31B7F13-FA80-42C0-8F26-0F371B101261.jpeg
Attached picture D80531EA-4A00-4FF8-980C-51E87C3D2F93.jpeg
Posted By: SNK-EYZ

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/18/20 04:05 AM

While some people say that oil pan is what to use on an A-Body because it has the indentation, it doesn't really work (as you have found out).

Both the 187 and the 699 oil pan have the indentation too far forward (close to the sump area).
They simply don't clear, I've got a factory 69 383 GTS and tried both the 187 and 699 oil pans when I was mocking up everything in the engine compartment for clearance and neither one cleared the center link at the idler arm.
The recess is in the wrong spot to clear.

I ended up using a 7 quart Hemi pan that I recessed my self with a hammer and a larger socket to make clearance.
I looked to see if I had a pic of the recess that I added, but none of the engine pics show that part of the oil pan.

Both the 187 and 699 oil pans are actually listed as C-Body oil pans.
http://www.440source.com/oilpans.htm
Posted By: chagjr

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/28/20 09:39 PM

I finally purchased an inspection camera. The motor has a forged crank., windage tray, and a double roller timing chain.
going to start tranny installation.

THANKS MOPARTS!
Posted By: 500ciDuster

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/28/20 11:16 PM

A few yours back a friend bought a 451 kit from Muscle Motors and the 440 crankshaft wasn't drilled but was spot faced, was the first one we had ever seen and I posted it on Moparts but was 15 years ago. Glad you confirmed and is good that its neutral balance
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/28/20 11:31 PM

Originally Posted by chagjr
Here is a photo of the balancer again-

See all those small not very deep drilled holes under the pulley in the balancer, that balancer looks a lot like one I have off of a forged steel crankshaft 400 truck stick shift motor work confused
I haven't seen a late model truck or motorhome 440 motor with a stick shifts so I have no idea if they shared a similar balancer like the 400 motors had for the stick shift cranks, DANG Mopar anyways for having so many different parts on similar motors whiney
Posted By: fourgearsavoy

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/29/20 12:36 AM

Originally Posted by 500ciDuster
A few yours back a friend bought a 451 kit from Muscle Motors and the 440 crankshaft wasn't drilled but was spot faced, was the first one we had ever seen and I posted it on Moparts but was 15 years ago. Glad you confirmed and is good that its neutral balance


I got an Eagle 4.15 crank in my 493 that isn't drilled for the pilot and I'm a stick shift guy rant sawzall

Gus beer
Posted By: 500ciDuster

Re: Help me identify this crankshaft - 05/30/20 01:24 AM

Gus, my friend loves four speed too but I told him "I guess this will be an auto!" I wanted him to go auto anyway
© 2024 Moparts Forums