Dash pad vs dash cap

Wanted to get some opinions on whats available and what "works" in regards to replacing a cracked dash pad (this is for a 70' Swinger). I'll use Classic Industries as examples so we all know what we're talking about.

I can get a true original style pad, vinyl over a metal core:
http://www.classicindustries.com/mopar/parts/ma1095338.html

Or an ABS cap:
http://www.classicindustries.com/mopar/parts/ma1094100.html

Price is basically the same - so WHY wouldn't I get the vinyl one that's just like the OEM? I am likely going to paint/dye whichever one I get - as I've redone all the interior pieces and want to ensure everything matches up exactly. I've always assumed the caps are likely big/bulky and look cheap - am I wrong? DO they offer any advantages?

Thanks - did a search but came up with a bunch of random threads that weren't what I was looking for....

In my experience it's tough not to have a dash cap look like a cap when it's done, which isn't the greatest. The benefit is you don't have to disassemble the dash to install a cap, so it's just a matter of how much time you want to spend and how fussy you are about the end result.

i use a cap on a 73 duster,you have to look hard to tell its a cap.i wouldnt think twice about using one again.its been on 13 years and still looks good

Dash caps are like toupees...

i think it also depends on the car on how it will look

The cap I bought is very light weight and looks pretty good. Not bulky by any means.

It was $50 shipped. I think it's whatever the budget allows on stuff like this.

Here is a link to a discussion on this subject earlier this year.

https://board.moparts.org/ubbthreads/show...rue#Post7690347

Scroll down about half way and see my comments. This is my two cents on this subject.

The "toupees" comment killed me .

I'll be going new pad I'd say. The install labor doesn't bother me - just had the dash out for paint, naturally I cracked the pad once it was back in the car.... thanks for the responses.

Quote:

---

i use a cap on a 73 duster,you have to look hard to tell its a cap.i wouldnt think twice about using one again.its been on 13 years and still looks good

---

I used an "Accuform" dash cap on my Aspen. Cost me about $70 in black, and I painted to color with SEM spray can. Looks really good, and also very hard to tell it's a cap. I followed their detailed instructions on the install, and I also wouldn't hesitate to use one again.