Moparts

noisy comp lifters

Posted By: mopfried

noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 11:37 AM

My hydraulic 284XE comp cam and comp lifters in my BB with 1.6 aluminum rockers are noisy. I have adjusted them tighter, looser and it doesn't make much difference. I am considering changing lifers. What if any break in will be needed for new lifers on a used cam?
Posted By: Yellow Fever

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 11:56 AM

Yup, gotta break em in just like before. I used crane anti pump ups in my 408 as recommended by Ryan J and it worked out good.

http://www.cranecams.com/product/cart.php?m=product_detail&p=24799
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 12:00 PM

What makes you think it's the lifters and what do you mean by noisey?
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 12:39 PM

It just sounds like it has solid lifters in it. I have tried 1/2-3/4-1 full turn and it still clicks like its out of adjustment. I understand the aluminum roller rockers may make it noisy.
Posted By: Yellow Fever

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 01:12 PM

Check to make sure the rockers clear the spring retainers ok.
Posted By: MLR426

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 01:23 PM


XE cams are aggressive on the ramp and do sound noisey.

MLR426
Posted By: Commando1

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 01:29 PM

Quote:


XE cams are aggressive on the ramp and do sound noisey.

MLR426



X2
End of story. Nothing you can do about it.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 02:29 PM

Nothing you can do that series of cams clatter--I think closing ramps are the culprit.
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 03:59 PM

I don't like it. Would switching to Iron rockers help quite it down any? I know I would lose a little lift...Im using 1.6 rockers now.
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 05:47 PM

Quote:

I don't like it. Would switching to Iron rockers help quite it down any? I know I would lose a little lift...Im using 1.6 rockers now.




no , you have to change the cam out to something stock and wimpy ...
Posted By: Yellow Fever

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 06:13 PM

Turn the radio up or drop the mufflers.
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 06:25 PM

Quote:

It just sounds like it has solid lifters in it. I have tried 1/2-3/4-1 full turn and it still clicks like its out of adjustment. I understand the aluminum roller rockers may make it noisy.


How are you adjsuting them, hot or cold? Are the heads aluminum ot iron? If aluminum make sure and set the preload hot I run a Comp Cams XE295HL cam and lifters in one of my 440 with Eddy RPM heads and Harland Sharp 1.5 rockers, nothing noisy in the valve train on it
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 06:50 PM

452 Iron heads. I adjust them cold 7/16-20 thread on the adjuster = .050 per turn. I loosen them and slowly tighten them until I feel drag on the push rod then turn them to what I am setting them at. Should I go more than one turn?
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 06:51 PM

Quote:

Quote:

I don't like it. Would switching to Iron rockers help quite it down any? I know I would lose a little lift...Im using 1.6 rockers now.




no , you have to change the cam out to something stock and wimpy ...




Thanks John... I already have 4 mufflers on it.... Its fairly quiet until I get into it.
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 07:03 PM

Quote:

452 Iron heads. I adjust them cold 7/16-20 thread on the adjuster = .050 per turn. I loosen them and slowly tighten them until I feel drag on the push rod then turn them to what I am setting them at. Should I go more than one turn?


I would try setting them warm, as a last resort I like and use the method of setting the valves by turning the motor over on the starter with one valve cover off until the exhaust valves starts to open and then set the preload on the intake rocker arm, I then bump the starter over until the intake valve opens all the way and starts to close a tiny little bit and then set the exhaust preload, same thing on the valve lash I usally do one side and then button that side up and run the motor some more to warm it back up and then do the other side I don't like or use the Mopar, Chevy charts
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 07:15 PM

Cab, I will try that.... How much preload?
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 10:03 PM

Quote:

452 Iron heads. I adjust them cold 7/16-20 thread on the adjuster = .050 per turn. I loosen them and slowly tighten them until I feel drag on the push rod then turn them to what I am setting them at. Should I go more than one turn?




7/16-20 adjusters ??? Those would be HUGE, all adjusters I have ever seen were 1/4-28
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 10:24 PM

On aluminum roller rockers?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Crane-99680-2-Ro...r#ht_1514wt_808
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/07/13 10:35 PM

Quote:

On aluminum roller rockers?

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Crane-99680-2-Ro...r#ht_1514wt_808




Well there you go , I have yet to use a set of alum roller

Now I need to look at the iron ductiles I have ...
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 12:20 AM

Quote:

Cab, I will try that.... How much preload?


On the 7/16 x 20 adjuster I would start with 1/2 turn warm or hot Let us know what you get
Posted By: 471Magnum

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 01:35 AM

Quote:

Quote:


XE cams are aggressive on the ramp and do sound noisey.

MLR426



X2
End of story. Nothing you can do about it.




X3

Reset the pre-load about have a dozen times on my XE275HL. I'm running Topline Johnson lifters (R-series IIRC). I can make it louder, but I can't make it quiet. Pretty much the nature of the beast.
Posted By: KnuckleDuster

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 04:57 PM

x4...

XE285HL
Comp pro Magnum rockers
Crane anti-pump up lifters

Been through the valves twice already trying to quiet it down, gonna go through once more hot and call it a day. Judging by the amount of noise thought maybe I did too little preload and had a pushrods bouncing off the rockers...???
Posted By: 67Satty

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 07:12 PM

x5

With all the clatter and messing around trying to adjust them, I don't see what the point of the big hydraulic cams is, might as well have a solid and make more power all other things being equal.

One thing I wish I would've done different with my 440.

Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 07:51 PM

hum... seems like the next 440 will have to have a roller...
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 08:18 PM

What is the big issue , are we all spoiled by how quiet our Prius is?



easy enough to fix , put in a cam with a chevy lobe like we only used to have in the past , problem solved

I don't understand why someone would go to the expense of installing an adjustable valvetrain on a hyd. cam ???
Posted By: mopfried

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 11:13 PM

My heads are cut .100 to make 452 heads closed chamber. I have access to machinery... or I did. Im to cheap to replace pistons and deck the block. I do it cause they say it cant be done. I also made my own cut to fit push rods. It just sounds like the oil pump is bad when you rev it up and the lifters rattle... I guess I can tell the chevy guys my cam is wiped while they see my tial lights and smell my tires.
Posted By: parksr5

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/08/13 11:53 PM

I have a XE275 and mine is noisy too. I've adjusted my valves once since the motor was put together and they really didn't even need it. I've heard many people say they are just noisy cams.
Posted By: BSB67

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 12:38 AM

Quote:

x5

With all the clatter and messing around trying to adjust them, I don't see what the point of the big hydraulic cams is, might as well have a solid and make more power all other things being equal.

One thing I wish I would've done different with my 440.






Agreed. Not to mention the quality issues with hydraulic lifters available today. So, faster ramps than ever, the need for much more spring pressure for control, and poor quality lifters that are generally more complicated. I doubt many are getting the performance out of their fast ramp cam profiles that they should. If you really care about performance, put a solid in it. Otherwise, put a lolli-pop cam in it, close the hood and forget about it.

I must really be the odd one out here. To me there is nothing sweeter than the sound of solids, and nothing say performance better.
Posted By: rapom

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 01:06 AM

I have a big hyd cam from straightline performance and I just replaced my lifters with a set from Comp cams. I was shocked that they just wanted the lash set from 0 to 1/8 of a turn as normally I would go to a 1/2 turn. Anyway I was surprised that they were as quiet as they were. Maybe it's because I am running M/T cast aluminum valve covers. (Very thick compared to some valve covers which may stifle the noise)
Posted By: BSB67

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 01:26 AM

Quote:

I have a big hyd cam from straightline performance and I just replaced my lifters with a set from Comp cams. I was shocked that they just wanted the lash set from 0 to 1/8 of a turn as normally I would go to a 1/2 turn. Anyway I was surprised that they were as quiet as they were. Maybe it's because I am running M/T cast aluminum valve covers. (Very thick compared to some valve covers which may stifle the noise)




It depends on the lobes. Some of the Straightline performance stuff I have seen has very gentle ramps.
Posted By: ahy

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 04:41 AM

Quote:

Quote:

x5

With all the clatter and messing around trying to adjust them, I don't see what the point of the big hydraulic cams is, might as well have a solid and make more power all other things being equal.

One thing I wish I would've done different with my 440.






Agreed. Not to mention the quality issues with hydraulic lifters available today. So, faster ramps than ever, the need for much more spring pressure for control, and poor quality lifters that are generally more complicated. I doubt many are getting the performance out of their fast ramp cam profiles that they should. If you really care about performance, put a solid in it. Otherwise, put a lolli-pop cam in it, close the hood and forget about it.

I must really be the odd one out here. To me there is nothing sweeter than the sound of solids, and nothing say performance better.




Me too. A little sewing machine sound is nice... the sound of power.
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 06:44 AM

Quote:



I don't understand why someone would go to the expense of installing an adjustable valvetrain on a hyd. cam ???





Come on.. a SMART guy like you asks this?
The guys at Comp suggest an adjustable valvetrain to achieve preload. With my limited cam knowledge, I can see how that having each rocker adjusted to a specific setting compared to being along for the ride on a common shaft....Makes sense to me.
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 02:21 PM

Quote:


I must really be the odd one out here. To me there is nothing sweeter than the sound of solids, and nothing say performance better.




You are not alone.
Posted By: JohnRR

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 02:27 PM

Quote:

Quote:



I don't understand why someone would go to the expense of installing an adjustable valvetrain on a hyd. cam ???





Come on.. a SMART guy like you asks this?
The guys at Comp suggest an adjustable valvetrain to achieve preload. With my limited cam knowledge, I can see how that having each rocker adjusted to a specific setting compared to being along for the ride on a common shaft....Makes sense to me.




True but if you are going to buy adjustable rocker you might as well get a solid cam for max performance ... and if I remember correctly aren't you switching to a solid cam ??? You could have saved a bunch of money and just bought one in the first place.
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 09:06 PM

John, you are always an asset here and I have learned to rarely question your advice. I'm not arguing with you here, just an alternative perspective.
I ran the stock rockers even with a Comp .545 cam and later developed valve stem wear. After reading online tech stuff, I stumbled upon Comp's advice about running adjustable valvetrain to achieve preload. I've since read that my valve stem wear could have been due to rocker geometry, rocker tip misalignment, etc.
My changes to my 440/493 are part of an ongoing improvement and learning process. I have no doubt that this engine is serving as an 8 cylinder set of "training wheels" and that my next build will greatly benefit from the lessons I have learned.
MANY of the members here are to be credited for helping me with it all.
Posted By: radar

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 09:16 PM

Quote:

Nothing you can do that series of cams clatter--I think closing ramps are the culprit.




This. I had the 275 and same thing. My solid .557 MP loose lash cam is quieter!
Posted By: Dcuda69

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 09:21 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

x5

With all the clatter and messing around trying to adjust them, I don't see what the point of the big hydraulic cams is, might as well have a solid and make more power all other things being equal.

One thing I wish I would've done different with my 440.






Agreed. Not to mention the quality issues with hydraulic lifters available today. So, faster ramps than ever, the need for much more spring pressure for control, and poor quality lifters that are generally more complicated. I doubt many are getting the performance out of their fast ramp cam profiles that they should. If you really care about performance, put a solid in it. Otherwise, put a lolli-pop cam in it, close the hood and forget about it.

I must really be the odd one out here. To me there is nothing sweeter than the sound of solids, and nothing say performance better.




Me too. A little sewing machine sound is nice... the sound of power.




Sounds like some guys spend more time adjusting valves on their big hydraulic flat tappets than I spent with my solid roller.If you're gonna run a big cam like that..might as well do a solid. I run the valves on mine in the spring(about 20 min tops) put the covers on and drive it all summer. The tight lash solids aren't even that loud...
Posted By: 71TrakPak

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/09/13 10:09 PM

Quote:

I have a big hyd cam from straightline performance and I just replaced my lifters with a set from Comp cams. I was shocked that they just wanted the lash set from 0 to 1/8 of a turn as normally I would go to a 1/2 turn. Anyway I was surprised that they were as quiet as they were. Maybe it's because I am running M/T cast aluminum valve covers. (Very thick compared to some valve covers which may stifle the noise)




Which set of lifters did you buy??? the Pro Magnum set are higher RPM lifters and require adjustable rockers w/ little to no lash as stated above. They are as close to a solid lift as you can get in a hydraulic. The "street" or lower rpm model may take the usual 1/2 or more turn. Verify which lifter set you have. Some of the lifter models do state noisy valve train as a side effect.

Good luck
Posted By: fourgearsavoy

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/10/13 02:16 AM

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

x5

With all the clatter and messing around trying to adjust them, I don't see what the point of the big hydraulic cams is, might as well have a solid and make more power all other things being equal.

One thing I wish I would've done different with my 440.






Agreed. Not to mention the quality issues with hydraulic lifters available today. So, faster ramps than ever, the need for much more spring pressure for control, and poor quality lifters that are generally more complicated. I doubt many are getting the performance out of their fast ramp cam profiles that they should. If you really care about performance, put a solid in it. Otherwise, put a lolli-pop cam in it, close the hood and forget about it.

I must really be the odd one out here. To me there is nothing sweeter than the sound of solids, and nothing say performance better.




Me too. A little sewing machine sound is nice... the sound of power.




Sounds like some guys spend more time adjusting valves on their big hydraulic flat tappets than I spent with my solid roller.If you're gonna run a big cam like that..might as well do a solid. I run the valves on mine in the spring(about 20 min tops) put the covers on and drive it all summer. The tight lash solids aren't even that loud...



Same here I adjusted them once on the test stand and once after about 5 passes three years ago.My valve train is pretty bulletproof though with bushed Isky iron rockers.
My XE HL Comp hydraulic was more annoying than the solid Comp I have in the Savoy now.I run it very tight though 12 intake and 14 exhaust cold.
Gus

Attached picture 7808934-006.JPG
Posted By: goldmember

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/10/13 05:33 PM

This is some shocking news! A noisy comp xe hyd cam? Really?? Sorry couldn't help it. It's not the lifters,it has nothing to do with .904 lobes or anything except the closing ramp,or lack of. Usually when this issue comes up hasn't it always been the lifters? adjustment? or some mystery? seems like it to me. You can get a great hyd(sounds all wrong to me too.LOL) camshaft that won't wear out the nerves from Tim @ Bullet cams.
Posted By: 74_360_Cuda

Re: noisy comp lifters - 08/14/13 01:43 AM

Same here, XR286HR, hate the noise!
© 2024 Moparts Forums