Is a shop doing the work or a buddy? If a shops involved I'd go with what they're familiar using. I don't see what ring and pinion brand you were looking at. The first kit shows bearings that aren't in it. The 2nd has timkens in it.
My last "hey buddy" job was on an '08 Mustang and I begged him to get everything from Randy's Ring & Pinion, and recommended factory gears. Too expensive! So he ordrerd parts from Summit and Jeg's and got 4:10 Richmond gears that you can never get all the noise out, shims that don't resemble anything that came out of the car, and I had a question about the new posi unit that neither place could answer. Everything turned out ok and he's happy but that little whine on coast would bug me in a new car with a v-6!