I say black them out. I blacked out the wheels on my Dart a couple years ago and love it. I get more comments about them than anything else.

Plus no more polishing!

I wasnt sure how I would like it so rather than powdercoat them I scuffed them with some 600 grit wiped them clean. Used a rattle can and shot a couple coats of black primer then a few coats of semi gloss black. It holds up extremely well. Plus if does get dinged I just grab the rattle and spay another coat. I've only had to touch-up the front wheels once wheel when dumbarses at the tire shop stuck the weights on the outside.