Moparts

Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters.

Posted By: 72Swinger

Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/12/14 06:30 AM

Shcroeder racing makes all kinds of splined torsion bars typically used in Nascar as sway bars. The 1.5" dia 48 spline seems to be pretty common and they can be had in length from 30 to 50". How tough would it be to make some female splined couplers that could go in place of the factory ancor and adapted to the control arms? These come it all kinds of diameters from 7/8" up to 2"+ and either hollow or solid. Would eliminate the "Mopars cant get enough front spring rate" problem for good http://www.schroedersteering.com/SwayBarPage.html
http://www.schroedersteering.com/RateChtPDFs/1-12barchart.pdf
Posted By: BigBlockMopar

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/12/14 11:08 AM

Something like this, only bigger;


http://www.shop.lunns.net/ekmps/shops/lu...0-pr--241-p.jpg


Not enough springrate options isn't the main problem I think with Mopars.
IMO the price of a set of (seemingly simple) bars is, for most hobbyists.

How much would a set of these Schroeder bars set you back?
How much would 4 fabbed spline adapters add to that, which have to be hexed on the outside and splines machined on the inside. I'm seeing an easy $100 here aswell.

I went from factory stock 0.87" bars to the 1" bars from JustSuspension, mainly because they were affordable @ $200 for the pair, AND the fact as a newby, you don't know what to expect from a larger bar at first.
Had I felt confident upfront the 1" bars are something that should have been mounted from the factory (A-body), I probably would have opted for the bigger, but higher priced FirmFeel bars.

Having 1" bars @ $200 cost in my car now, I'm not really eager to plunk down $350 for a pair of 1.06" or 1.12" bars again.
Posted By: brads70

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/12/14 02:44 PM

You would need some sort of clip so they wouldn't come out of the socket too. ( both the bar and the new hex piece)
That would weaken the torsion bar.
I think there is enough range with the current available bars?
Posted By: Dan@Hotchkis

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/12/14 04:01 PM

We looked at making them, and the cost was too prohibitive.
Posted By: 72Swinger

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/12/14 08:44 PM

Quote:

You would need some sort of clip so they wouldn't come out of the socket too. ( both the bar and the new hex piece)
That would weaken the torsion bar.
I think there is enough range with the current available bars?


Just the clip inside the female end at the crossmember just like stock. A c clip snap ring, done. I would rather "convert" the car than "adapt" to existing hexes. On the lower arms just cut the hexes like in half,depth wise, and weld the 1.5" 48 females to it. Might be cool to have a little bit of male hex that indexes into the remaining control arm hex to help the welds out. I think it could be done, if I was smart enough to manufacture it lol.
Posted By: cudazappa

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 12:59 AM

Quote:

We looked at making them, and the cost was too prohibitive.




About 10 years ago there was some talk about doing this and I went out and bought some splined ends to see about this.

From a production standpoint, it all comes down to having the right broach for each bar you can use. That's a lot in tooling right there. Have a machine shop set up to run the super limited run that it will be. That's not cheap either.

Finally it got to the point of strength and wall thickness and who wants to deal with that liability?

Then you find out Firm Feel is willing to custom forge bars.

Death of that project soon after.

Besides, do you really need a larger than 1.25" T-bar? In an A-body? Really?

Hotchkis makes ~1.1" work on their E-body setup. That's a good dual purpose size. I'm running 1.18s and they are livable with 15" tires (still running bilsteins so my 17s are kind of harsh). Mitch swears by his 1.24s (that's about 450# wheel rate).
Posted By: 72Swinger

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 02:56 AM

The benifit would be these are gundrilled and can be had in all different sizes but with the same 1.5" 48 spline broach. B and E bodies would benefit the most being able to go past what is possible with stock hexes. These are all over ebay for $150 pair in 37.5" length.
Posted By: Dan@Hotchkis

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 04:50 AM

I'd like to see what rate you could get to where you could crack the windshield. We had to stop testing on the shaker rig because we almost did.
Posted By: BigBlockMopar

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 10:22 AM

If you really want to easily swap between splined torsionbars I think you could fab something like this, to slide into the existing LCA and TBar anchor, and install the torsionbar in between;

(Quick Photoshop-mockup. Dimensions are wrong)



Attached picture 8298711-TBarAdapter.jpg
Posted By: BigBlockMopar

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 10:26 AM

Come to think of it, the above won't work with fixed tbar anchors.
(I was thinking about the removable anchors the pre'65 fullsize Mopars have.)
Posted By: cudazappa

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 05:31 PM

Quote:

I'd like to see what rate you could get to where you could crack the windshield. We had to stop testing on the shaker rig because we almost did.




I got some excess railroad tracks on the side of my shop if you're looking for something to weld in
Posted By: jcc

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 05:59 PM

Quote:

If you really want to easily swap between splined torsionbars I think you could fab something like this, to slide into the existing LCA and TBar anchor, and install the torsionbar in between;

(Quick Photoshop-mockup. Dimensions are wrong)






That is a solution, but ease or ability to install is your next hurdle. Would also shorten the effective twist length of the bar and therefore increase its rate, and/or increase the stress on the bar. Same adapter could be designed but use the larger C body Hex instead of spline, and as mentioned, vary the inner dimension to vary/fine tune rate, and bypass the broaching operation.
Posted By: 72Swinger

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 08:47 PM

The rear hexes need to be 86'd for the female sleeve. Like I said earlier, it would have to be a conversion not an adaptation.
Posted By: jcc

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 10:10 PM

Quote:

The rear hexes need to be 86'd for the female sleeve. Like I said earlier, it would have to be a conversion not an adaptation.




Not exactly sure why, care to explain, I'm trying to stay KISS, and we do have a solution already in place with C body hex larger bars (FirmFeel)

I suspect I don't understand clearly what the main issue here is, we need more variance in fine tuning TB rates (thats a small group I suspect), we need greater custom clocking, we need larger then 1.24" TBs, we need lighter TB's with similar rates (hallow), or what? Seems like one issue soon with the ideas thrown out will be ease of installing the TB, which its not clear to me how adaptors solve that. It we are trying to not cut up/modify the rear TB crossmember, we gots a tough problem, if that's ok, there are a lot of solutions.
Posted By: 72Swinger

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 11:00 PM

Just a brainstorm, carry on.
Posted By: brads70

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/13/14 11:59 PM

IMO Mopars are for sure sprung way to lite from the factory but...
( again IMO) there comes a point when too stiff of a torsion bar just masks the real issue of the front end geometry not being optimal. Too stiff and you basically have little or no suspension, so the negative movement's don't happen, it's just a bigger go-cart. With Mopar's and any unibody design the whole car is a big torsion bar. I'f you limit it too much in one area it has to flex at the next weakest spot. Popped spot welds, ripped out mounts, broken windshields etc...
Unless your doing some serious high speed/high banked road course racing I'm guessing Firm Feel has us all covered?
If your building a dedicated race car that's a different story, they are a "consumable" and not intended to last indefinitely. "Lifespan" is below being competitive on a priority list. No one builds race cars to last 40 years. Most everyone on here runs our cars mainly on the street .
Just my
Posted By: DGS

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/14/14 04:12 PM

Just did a few calculations:

Hex opening: 1,25" - no larger TB can be fitted through the TB anchor.
1,5" spline bar ends have enough meat to be machined down to a hex of 1,25" (distance between opposite flat sides not corners).

So if you get splined bars with 1,5" ends and a diameter no larger than 1,25" you could turn them into regular hex bars if you have access to the necessary machining equipment.

Unfortunately most bars I keep finding in the right diameter are only 37.5" long...
Posted By: Mopar Mitch

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/14/14 06:57 PM

Cudazappa (Gary) - The 1.24 TBs are rated at 425 lbs/in. As you know, my car was originally setup for national SCCA Solo II competition (first it was F/Stock, later E/Street Prepared.. a great fun class!)... flat smooth courses (airports, huge parking lots, etc). Progressively changing the TBs also went with changing the rear leafs, as well as the shocks... eventually changing the valving on the Konis to better match the TBs and leafs. The sway bars were also progressively changed in their diameters... fine tuning them with the different combos of end-link bushings (rubber/poly), same with the adjustability of the Koni shocks -- all to my personal satisfaction, as well as with input and track-testing (pylon events) by a few highly regarded and pro-racers. Limits were restricted by SCCA class rules.

After campaigning it for well over 20 years, fine-tuning, etc, it handles pretty good and will keep up with anything out there (and I've taken a break/hiatus sionce ~2001 ~2010). Just ask anyone who's driven or raced it. The ultimate matter depends upon having fresh soft tires, and the skill of the driver on that given day. also, pylon courses mandate the driver to memorize the course layout, and positioning of the car, etc -- a huge factor in time for any day's competition autocross results; road courses also mandate familiarization, and lapping experience is a plus!

Hi-speed road course events is what I've been doing for the past 3-4 years as time and $$ allows -- car handles great... pretty much the same setup as I've settled upon many years ago (actually, its a little heavier with minor changes). Again, limiting factors are just the tires.

Street/hwy driving with the car's stiff setup is no big deal... no cracks, broken welds, windshiled, etc... I have different rims/tires pending where/what I'm doing with the car; naturally, driving on the "street" requires avoiding pot-holes, slow-crossing over RR tracks, etc... I've said before... "street" driving doesn't count as you can't truly enjoy the car; highway driving is great and very enjoyable!... typically 1-2-3 hour (sometimes longer, even cross-country!) driving is no problem... comfort is a-ok.

In retrospect, look at the size of the Posey TA/Gurney AAR cars' TBs (and leaf springs)... I beleieve the TBs are ~1.4+" diameter... of course full roll-cages, re-welding, etc.... and where they are intended to be driven... smooth road courses.... So, the 1.24 are pretty small, on that note.

FF will make the 1.24 TBs for anyone interested, or 1.22, or 1.20 (they already offer 1.18)... and for most Mopar ppl, if they eventually choose increasing the TB size and rate, they will find them to be one of the best overall improvements... BUT, its a "package" of other mods that have to follow... leafs, shocks, sway bars... bushings, steering box/wheel, driver's seat, vehicle weight reduction, weight balancing (side-to-side). Also, I'm certain that adding SFC, and re-welding the k-frame, adding a roll-bar/cage, etc., will help for the unibody's torsional rigidity... honestly, that's one thing I've never done (again, SCCA rules restrictions/limitations in the past classes that I've run)... Some of those rules have since changed, so, I'll probably eventually add welded-in SFC), also, I may even change the setup towards other club's class rules, etc -- but always following a "rule book" so that the mods are not done foolishly with wasted $$$ (so many items items out there offered by different companies, don't fit within certain club's allowable "rules", so, be careful!). The car is rust free and has survived extremely well throughout all of its competative years... and street/hwy driving, too! Its very enjoyable to drive anywhere, anytime.

Attached picture 8300012-Mitch'sTA.jpg
Posted By: 340duster340

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 05:21 AM

Not sure if it would work or be practical..... But could you run t-bars and coil-overs to get the desired spring rate?
Posted By: feets

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 03:58 PM

Quote:

Not sure if it would work or be practical..... But could you run t-bars and coil-overs to get the desired spring rate?





I have a great idea!

Rip out the T-bars and weld in solid blocks to prevent all suspension movement!


Is that what you guys are looking for?

Seriously now, have you honestly calculated the spring rates available and determined that you need more?

I detect a pointless downward spiral going on.
Posted By: Mopar Mitch

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 04:43 PM

340duster -- good idea! I've never even thought of that, but not sure if any such options existed back then or even now. The current setup works great for me and has proved itself very well.
Posted By: Supercuda

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 04:56 PM

Quote:

Not sure if it would work or be practical..... But could you run t-bars and coil-overs to get the desired spring rate?




For some data here, there are several down sides to adding coil overs. First, it will add unsprung weight. Next, the upper shock mounts were never designed to handle spring loads, so you will have to reinforce. Then there is the spring rate needed. You may find that you cannot get coil over springs soft enough to work with your existing T bars. Finally, you will most likely have to run aftermarket upper control arms to provide clearance for the coil overs.

It might be doable, but it may also make more sense just to convert over completely to coil overs and open up room for the exhaust.
Posted By: Mopar Mitch

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 05:24 PM

Regarding coil-overs, John Sandbergs SCCA C/Prepared AAR eventually ousted the TBs (1.24) and he went to yet stiffer rate coil overs (becuase the 1.24 TBs weren't stiff enough... and had he considered swapping hexes he would have done that but concentrated on the entirely new setup instead).. and the class rules permitted the swap.... he did the same in the rear (ousting the metal xxhd leafs)... he completely re-designed the suspension front and rear (professionally engineered).. result: eventual higher class finishes/more wins and the SCCA national championship C/PL crown. There's a place for coil overs when the TBs aren't stiff enough. Suspension travel remains acceptable for the intended roads/courses driven (always following club rules!, etc). His previous TB/leaf complete overall setup, etc, now resides in his son's 73 440-6 Challenger (also has full fiberglass front end)... street/hwy driven, occasional road course lapping sessions.. an awesome car!

You can read about John's SCCA C/P AAR in Mopar Action issue August 2006 along with my T/A for most of the details. (John's AAR was also featured in Mopar Collector's Guide about 1-1/2 years ago.)

John did install splined sway bars front/rear.... many variable choices in that segment.
Posted By: TC@HP2

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/15/14 05:35 PM

With the current shock technology out there and Firm Feel's willingness to make a custom diameter t-bar, I'd say that the rates are pretty well covered for everyone but all out race efforts. By using custom splined s-bars with modular arms, they will yield better on road handling and ride improvements for a street going car than going to wrist sized t-bars.

If you still need something bigger than a 1.24 t-bar for your race car, you can always convert to C body sockets and talk to Firm Feel about custom t-bars they can tool up for you in the 1.40 range, which is upwards of around 750# wheel rate, or roughly twice what the Hotchkis Challenger is using currently.

The only big advantage I could see of using the splined adapter in a stock suspended mopar would be to give you less expensive bar options so you could carry around dozens of sets to change out for track conditions. Even at that, you are only saving 50% per set, but, you also have all the upfront costs for the adapters.
Posted By: RylisPro

Re: Someone needs to make splined t-bars adapters. - 10/16/14 12:07 AM

Yes I agree about the not needing bigger bars. I have 1.12's and a full cage on my setup. I didn't really feel or exhibit any excess body roll and my buddy following me at the track up in Thunderhill West said the same thing. Granted I wasn't going that fast as it is a tighter track mostly in 3rd gear, but I never really felt that the front end was out of control or didn't want to go in the direction I chose to point it.

I have taken as much weight off the front end with fiberglass and aluminum engine parts though. It maybe a different story with big block iron engines. I feel that reducing the front end weight would balance the car even further, only then would I even consider 1.24 torsion bars
© 2024 Moparts Forums