Moparts

Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs??

Posted By: WarEagle1

Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 04:57 PM

My Gen II Hemi starts to break up in the 6000-6500 rpm range. This was not the case originally but has started in the last year or so. It only has a few thousand miles on it. Build is 4-5 years old.
Cam is a Lunati hydraulic roller: 231/235 @ .050"; .535/.550 lift.
Springs (recc. by Lunati) are installed at 139# on the seat and 325# open (per their recommendation).
Valve gear is all stock.
Does that sound like enough spring?
Or any other thoughts are welcome. Thanks.
Posted By: INTMD8

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 05:35 PM

Doesn't sound like enough spring to me but that isn't the only factor.

Weight is as well, so if you are running a large diameter spring I would replace it with something with more pressure, smaller overall diameter and Ti retainer. (Not that it was asked but I would prefer solid roller as well)

That being said your current spring pressure may be enough if they are beehives.

Next I would make sure you have stiff enough pushrods.
Posted By: A39Coronet

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 05:43 PM

You sure it's not ignition related? I'd be swapping out coil or ignition box before I pulled a valve spring unless you find broken ones (could be product of valve float).
Posted By: Dragula

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 05:47 PM

Those seem light....Hemi's are very sensitive with respect to valve train. If its not lean, I would swap springs.
Posted By: an8sec70cuda

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 07:34 PM

Originally Posted by A39Coronet
You sure it's not ignition related? I'd be swapping out coil or ignition box before I pulled a valve spring unless you find broken ones (could be product of valve float).

iagree I'd rule out the ignition system first. twocents

I also agree that those spring pressures seem light for a heavy hemi valvetrain.
Posted By: cudaman1969

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 08:49 PM

Before we were smart, the Hemi we raced would shoot ducks at 6500 in the 1/4 mile, we only ran 1/8 mile tracks, we re jetted, changed plugs, wires and cap. We were running ONE holly blue with the cross ram and Hollys, was a while before the light came on that we DIDNT have enough fuel in the first place. Check your carbs and fuel supply. How did I learn? I was wrenching on the buddy’s 69 Stang with a 588 cu in Shotgun Roush engine, twin dominators at over 830 hp, popping on the top end same way (8.90 @152) a pro stock guy clued us in, you guessed it, one holly blue. In 1983 no less.
Posted By: WarEagle1

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 09:11 PM

Thanks for the responses guys.
I didn't mention initially but this is a street car, 477 C.I. with FAST EFI (throttle body). Fuel pressure is 45-47 psi.
Ignition is an MP chrome box, recurved distributor, and a 45kV coil.
The condition started after a couple of years. It's not driven much. Used to pull rock solid up to 6500; I don't push it much beyond that.
I recently read an old article about Dudek's Hemi and he said it wouldn't buzz past 5000 with 160# / 390# springs (with a similar cam). Just got me thinking about the springs.
So, for the ignition check out, can I bypass the ballast for a quick test. Seems I've done that in the past.
Posted By: Wirenut

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 09:50 PM

Can you drive around it ? Meaning if you lift just a bit does it go away?
I had a problem once that turned out to be a clogged fuel filter . symptom was similar.
Start with simple .
Posted By: INTMD8

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/22/21 09:59 PM

Do you have a data log or screen shot of such?
Posted By: Hot 340

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/23/21 01:04 AM

Condensation bites me every year. Try some drygas. I kid you not.
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/23/21 01:42 AM

It sounds like ignition miss to me or the valve springs.
I use to race NHRA stock back when we had to use the original stock valve spring and cam specs, the first motor was a 1968 Street hemi that had 125 lbs. on the seats and 325 Lbs. open with stock lift which was right at .484 lift at the retainers on the intake valves and right at .466 net on the exhaust side, we switch the first motor into a 1970 Challenger with a hydraulic lifter cheater cam and use the same valve spring specs on it, both motors would pull really hard to 7000 RPM with a Hayes S4 ignition box, now known as Stinger ignitions.
I race another NHRA stocker 1970 hemi car with the early Mopar chrome box with the blue heat sink and it would pull hard to 7000 RPM also thumbs
My message is to try one thing at a time but in your case I would look at the valve springs first twocents
Did you modify the oil system in the block to oil the rockers full time? If not that is worth doing up, Especially on a street motor that gets the oil hot and valve springs hot for long periods of time work
I groove the #4 cam journal to do that and restrict the holes size to the rocker arms depending on which rocker arms are on the motor, roller rocker on the shaft get a .040 oil restrictor, non roller rockers on the shaft get no restrictor scope
On your deal I would look at 225+ lbs. on the seats and 480 Lbs.+ open depending on how much net lift you have. If over .600 net lift look at 580 to 650 Lbs. open pressure and near 250+ lbs. on the seats twocents
you can NOT hurt a steel core solid roller cam with to much valve spring pressure, you can tear up the rollers with to little work twocents
If you can see bright stripes on the back side of the outer edge of the cam lobes you don't have enough valve spring pressure scope
Posted By: INTMD8

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/23/21 02:01 AM

He's on a hydro roller though ^

With smaller diameter spring, ti retainer I would guess somewhere in the 180/425 range.

I've ran more on hydraulic roller but can start tracking/damaging the cam if a 5150 core
Posted By: dthemi

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/23/21 10:29 AM

I've never seen a hydro go past 6500 in a hemi without a lot of work. I'd bet it's just that it's a hydro. More spring will help, but only to a point.
Posted By: fbs63

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/23/21 11:06 AM

Originally Posted by dthemi
I've never seen a hydro go past 6500 in a hemi without a lot of work. I'd bet it's just that it's a hydro. More spring will help, but only to a point.

This. The HEAVY valve train in a Hemi does not like hydraulic cams.
Posted By: 71birdJ68

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 02:13 AM

What he said. I have a 528 that just wouldn't run past 6000. Hyd roller. Ray Barton says that they start floating at 5 something. I'm in the process right now of changing to a solid roller. The engine acted lazy.
Posted By: BigBlockGTS

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 11:59 AM

The limits of a hydraulic roller makes sense but how did he pull 6500 rpm before?
Posted By: INTMD8

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 12:14 PM

What is the reason it wouldn't rev with a hydraulic?

I don't like the idea of running one on a hemi due to pushrod angularity but can't think of any reason you -couldn't- get it to 7k just because it's hydraulic
Posted By: 71birdJ68

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 02:57 PM

The rockers with the crazy push rods are just to heavy for a hyd to handle. The spring pressures required won't work with a hyd.
Posted By: INTMD8

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 03:19 PM

I guess that's the reason I ask as far as what specific to Hemi as I've ran 200 seat 450 open and nearly 8k rpm on other hydraulic roller engines with 1.8 rockers and smaller diameter lifters.

With 1.8 rocker that would put 360/810 pound load to the lifter. With the same spring pressures on a hemi and say 1.52 ratio that would put 304/684 pound load to the lifter.

I could see the hemi not getting there due to mass of rockers but don't think pushrod weight should matter much. (at least I've not seen weight on the actuation side clip usable rpm range).

Either way, agreed that I don't like the idea due to pushrod angularity, just wondering if anyone has actually tried higher spring pressure and lighter valves/springs/retainers with hyd roller on a hemi or just didn't as they assumed the lifters couldn't take it.
Posted By: dthemi

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 03:32 PM

Originally Posted by INTMD8
I guess that's the reason I ask as far as what specific to Hemi as I've ran 200 seat 450 open and nearly 8k rpm on other hydraulic roller engines with 1.8 rockers and smaller diameter lifters.

With 1.8 rocker that would put 360/810 pound load to the lifter. With the same spring pressures on a hemi and say 1.52 ratio that would put 304/684 pound load to the lifter.

I could see the hemi not getting there due to mass of rockers but don't think pushrod weight should matter much. (at least I've not seen weight on the actuation side clip usable rpm range).

Either way, agreed that I don't like the idea due to pushrod angularity, just wondering if anyone has actually tried higher spring pressure and lighter valves/springs/retainers with hyd roller on a hemi or just didn't as they assumed the lifters couldn't take it.



A wedge with a hydro roller is a completely different animal, and no where near the same load on the valve train. Weight, compound angles, length, length of rocker ect. When you start going to ti valves, retainers, locks, spread lifters, and tons of oil management to make a hydro work, you're already where no one wants to go. Better to buy a high quality set of solids, a small mechanical, and rev to the moon whenever ya want.

I get the desire to run a hydro on the street, but beyond that, it seems like wasted energy to me.
Posted By: WarEagle1

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/24/21 07:23 PM

Thanks for all of the good input guys.

I'll do some testing to rule out fuel and ignition. Don't have any way to log data.
I was hoping someone had success with adding 20# with some shims and calling it a day. grin I guess nothing's that easy (although I did cure a similar issue that way with a W-2 stroker motor, but it had TONS of installed height to work with).

If I had to build this one again, I'd probably skip the roller set-up and just go with a flat tappet... more cam choices (street) and would save a LOT of $ and a lot of pushrod clearancing work, etc.
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Big Hemi breaks up over 6000. Valve springs?? - 06/25/21 04:01 AM

I would look at installing a .060 shim in one cylinder and then check for coil bind at your current lift, if it has .100 + to coil bind run it. scope up
If it has less than .050 don't down
© 2024 Moparts Forums