Moparts

Rocker Arms to tight?

Posted By: pgccp

Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/10/14 10:34 PM

Iam reassembling my 383 had heads plained ( not very much) rockers seem to be very tight on valves when valves are closed stock shaft and rockers, rockers are riding valve tips ok. push rods are tight on closed vales. Should I install shims and how much? Push rods should be able to turn on a closed valve? Thanks Bob
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 12:27 AM

Quote:

Iam reassembling my 383 had heads plained ( not very much) rockers seem to be very tight on valves when valves are closed stock shaft and rockers, rockers are riding valve tips ok. push rods are tight on closed vales. Should I install shims and how much? Push rods should be able to turn on a closed valve? Thanks Bob




I assume your talking a hyd cam.... get one of the
valve on base and start pulling the shaft 1/4 turn
at a time on each bolt till the push rod turns freely
and count the 1/4 turns... then tell us.... if you
know how much you had the heads cut we can tell
Posted By: pgccp

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 02:23 AM

Thanks for getting back to me I will get the info tomorrow
can not remember the amount removed from the heads but it was not very much yes it is hyd lifters. Thanks again Bob
Posted By: rowin4

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 04:54 AM

Did you also have a valve job? I have seen valves set so far into the seat that when the head assembly was put on the valves were open on the base circle, you might have the same problem.

Posted By: JohnRR

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 05:43 PM

Quote:

Iam reassembling my 383 had heads plained ( not very much) rockers seem to be very tight on valves when valves are closed stock shaft and rockers, rockers are riding valve tips ok. push rods are tight on closed vales. Should I install shims and how much? Push rods should be able to turn on a closed valve? Thanks Bob




No , you do not install shims , shims are for correcting valve tip to rocker arm geometry , not making up for head/block milling.

It's a hyd. lifter not solid , the lifter should be compressed some and under that pressure the pushrod will not spin freely .
Posted By: MRMOPAR622

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 05:50 PM

You didn't step up to a bigger cam did you?Best cure is to put adjustable rockers on it along with some lash caps.
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 05:53 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Iam reassembling my 383 had heads plained ( not very much) rockers seem to be very tight on valves when valves are closed stock shaft and rockers, rockers are riding valve tips ok. push rods are tight on closed vales. Should I install shims and how much? Push rods should be able to turn on a closed valve? Thanks Bob




No , you do not install shims , shims are for correcting valve tip to rocker arm geometry , not making up for head/block milling.

It's a hyd. lifter not solid , the lifter should be compressed some and under that pressure the pushrod will not spin freely .




John is correct... no shims... IF it is compressed
to far then you need shorter push rods... does any
one know the dimension from the shaft center line
to the push rod center line(even a close spec)..
that will help also to figure out the compression
of the lifter... the reason I ask is I'm not home
to get any measurements or any books on hand
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 06:41 PM

Quote:

You didn't step up to a bigger cam did you?Best cure is to put adjustable rockers on it along with some lash caps.




Exactly, no more bs guess work...............
Posted By: dogdays

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 06:56 PM

I keep thinking this: it's a hydraulic cam, right? There is supposed to be no lash in the system when the valve is closed, that's what the hydraulic lifters do.
There's a spring inside the lifter that pushes the cup up. If you had slop in the closed condition the pushrods would be too short.
The question is, what kind of preload are you getting on the lifters. In other words, how far down in the lifter is the pushrod pushing the cup?

R.
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:05 PM

Quote:

I keep thinking this: it's a hydraulic cam, right? There is supposed to be no lash in the system when the valve is closed, that's what the hydraulic lifters do.
There's a spring inside the lifter that pushes the cup up. If you had slop in the closed condition the pushrods would be too short.
The question is, what kind of preload are you getting on the lifters. In other words, how far down in the lifter is the pushrod pushing the cup?

R.




Correct..... the other guys are jumping the gun...
if its .010 to .015 farther down in the lifter it
wont matter... so why BUY rockers for no reason...
yes a adjustable push rod is the easy way but if he
doesnt have one then a little math works fine
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:16 PM

Quote:

Iam reassembling my 383 had heads plained ( not very much) rockers seem to be very tight on valves when valves are closed stock shaft and rockers, rockers are riding valve tips ok. push rods are tight on closed vales. Should I install shims and how much? Push rods should be able to turn on a closed valve? Thanks Bob




Also.... NO the push rods should NOT turn... they
have pre-load on them pushing the lifter cup down in
which is what the hyd lifters need to make things
quiet
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:44 PM

The reason for adjustable rockers Mike is to step up to the 20th century already.............
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:50 PM

Quote:

The reason for adjustable rockers Mike is to step up to the 20th century already.............




Its STOCK.... I like spending others money also
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:52 PM

I get it BUT Isky iron or a cheaper version takes the guess work out and you can even play w/preload like we used to at Pettis on the stockers.............
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 07:59 PM

Quote:

I get it BUT Isky iron or a cheaper version takes the guess work out and you can even play w/preload like we used to at Pettis on the stockers.............




No I dont think you do get it... its STOCK... we dont
even know if he will EVER hit the track to see what
it might do..... I think you should buy a dana.. because
your 8 3/4 MIGHT blow up... get my point... we love
spending someone elses money
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:06 PM

You`re stuck in your ways and me in mine. ANYTIME a head is milled or valves sunk from valve jobs, the pre load`s out of wack period and shimming makes the already sucky small block`s sweep worse so adjustable rockers are the only LOGICAL solution...........I`m gonna go work out now.............. One more thing; if the stem heights are all over like some I`ve seen at least you can even things out w/an adj. rocker.............
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:13 PM

Quote:

You`re stuck in your ways and me in mine. ANYTIME a head is milled or valves sunk from valve jobs, the pre load`s out of wack period and shimming makes the already sucky small block`s sweep worse so adjustable rockers are the only LOGICAL solution...........I`m gonna go work out now..............




Never mind... I quit... you tell him what he needs
Posted By: GTX MATT

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:15 PM

Please invite me to the ensuing about which rockers to run and what rocker geometry is best
Posted By: Sport440

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:20 PM

Not being able to turn them with preload isnt exactly true. The tension with lifter preload isnt all that strong, especially with a motor thats been off. You will be able to tell the difference though between free turn and preload turn.
Posted By: Mopar Guy

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:20 PM

P Body & Thumperdart you bouth have a point but i lean more to P Body´s surgestion as i agree to help the guy out whitout spending more money then nessesary and i gues its not a top end race engine
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:25 PM

Not trying to be right but "been there done that" many, many times and I stand behind my "opinion" %100000000................I don`t EVER guess on ANYTHING car related but also understand I`m a nobody and that`s cool by me...........
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:31 PM

Quote:

Not trying to be right but "been there done that" many, many times and I stand behind my "opinion" %100000000................I don`t EVER guess on ANYTHING car related but also understand I`m a nobody and that`s cool by me...........




Well your guessing right now.... we have very little
facts about the build... no one said valve job was
done... was it .002 taken off the heads or .020..
it he measures first he will have a idea.. instead
of just throwing dollars at it
Posted By: Mopar Guy

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 08:34 PM

Quote:

Not trying to be right but "been there done that" many, many times and I stand behind my "opinion" %100000000................I don`t EVER guess on ANYTHING car related but also understand I`m a nobody and that`s cool by me...........




Thumper im no expert of any kind and im not trashing anybody just have an opinion and im still learning from my mistakes like i always have and guy´s like Smokie in his best D garage is the guy´s i try to learn from
Posted By: dvw

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/11/14 11:55 PM

Why not remove the intake and measure the preload? Bend a couple pieces of thin wire 90* at the end, various thickness. Use them as a go/no go gauge between the retaining ring and lifter piston. For what its worth I've shimmed plenty of shafts due to milling. Have 3 cars running around right now. Big block with a small .460" hydraulic a 7000 rpm small block with a .540"/.570" @ 245* solid. For that matter my rocker stands for my T&Ds are shimmed .125" cause I was to cheap to buy another $400 set of pushrods. No issue with that one either. I actually mapped out the geometry change, we're talking about .010" difference in sweep across the valve at .800" lift.
Doug
Posted By: Sport440

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 01:29 AM

I dont think the OP has alot of wire with various thicknesses hanging around.

I myself am still waiting to hear how much the heads were shaved.

If its .010 bolt it up and go , if there was no valve job.

If its alot more then that, different pushrods or shims as you suggest. Shims with Stock steel heads have had some pedestal breakage issues.

The OP is supposed to respond back tonight, Im going to wait to see, he responded last night at 7.30 or so.
Posted By: rowin4

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 04:33 AM

Quote:

Why not remove the intake and measure the preload? Bend a couple pieces of thin wire 90* at the end, various thickness. Use them as a go/no go gauge between the retaining ring and lifter piston. For what its worth I've shimmed plenty of shafts due to milling. Have 3 cars running around right now. Big block with a small .460" hydraulic a 7000 rpm small block with a .540"/.570" @ 245* solid. For that matter my rocker stands for my T&Ds are shimmed .125" cause I was to cheap to buy another $400 set of pushrods. No issue with that one either. I actually mapped out the geometry change, we're talking about .010" difference in sweep across the valve at .800" lift.
Doug





Shimming rocker stands is one thing, shimming shafts is another. The rocker shaft is made to fit into the shaft mount, putting shims under the shaft will make the bottom of the shaft bigger therefore upon tightening spreads the shaft mount and splitting it.
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 05:20 AM

After waiting several days to see where this post was going to end up at I suggest you take the intake manifold and intake valley pan off and remove the passenger side rocker shaft and rocker arms, also remove all the pushrods on the drivers side except for #1 cylinder, once that is done remove all the spark plugs and rotate the motor over so you get the motor stopped at Top Dead Center on the firing stroke on #1 cylinder(verify that location based off of the distributor rotor pointing at the #1 spark plug wire and the tinming mark on the crankshaft balancer ) once you get that done then put the drivers side rocker arm shaft and rocker arms with the two pushrods in place for that cylinder, torque them down to no more than 23 Ft. LBs Then you can look at the lifter to see how much the pushrod seat is down from the top of the retaining ring or clip. See if you can use a small paper clip and a large paper clip to make a L gauge out of to see if one of them will fit betwenn the pushrod cup in the lifter and the retainer, snap ring , keeper or what ever you want to call it . If a small paper clip will fit and large one won't your golden, if a large fits real loosely in between them you may need help in resolving the issue Maybe not If the large one fits you can try using different diameters of gas welding rod to measure with to find out exactly how much preload you have on those two lifters Don't you love working on motors that have been modified I do Good luck, let us know what you do and find out please
Posted By: dvw

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 05:44 AM

Quote:

Quote:

Why not remove the intake and measure the preload? Bend a couple pieces of thin wire 90* at the end, various thickness. Use them as a go/no go gauge between the retaining ring and lifter piston. For what its worth I've shimmed plenty of shafts due to milling. Have 3 cars running around right now. Big block with a small .460" hydraulic a 7000 rpm small block with a .540"/.570" @ 245* solid. For that matter my rocker stands for my T&Ds are shimmed .125" cause I was to cheap to buy another $400 set of pushrods. No issue with that one either. I actually mapped out the geometry change, we're talking about .010" difference in sweep across the valve at .800" lift.
Doug





Shimming rocker stands is one thing, shimming shafts is another. The rocker shaft is made to fit into the shaft mount, putting shims under the shaft will make the bottom of the shaft bigger therefore upon tightening spreads the shaft mount and splitting it.




I've used these for builds over the last 25 years.
http://chucker54.stores.yahoo.net/rocshafshim.html
Have never had a shaft crack or split. There is as much sectional area of the shim as there is of the pedestal. Therefore the load would be supported the same. Is the rocker geometry perfect,no. However availible small block rocker arms don't have perfect geometry either. Ideally with more lift the shaft should be lowered with a shorter pushrod. We're not talking Pro Stock. Will shimming work if the pushrod is a little long from milling or valve job, absolutely. Cab has the right idea to check it. Go from there.
Doug
Posted By: 71yelladustr

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 06:05 AM

In the past when I have had the problem with too much lifter preload with a hyd. cam in a mopar with all factory valve train components (solid pushrods),I have had great success with simply grinding the one end of the pushrod down a little to get the desired preload. Then sand it smooth and install the ground end in to the hardened cup of the lifter. A little time consuming, but works FINE. I have done this on several engines with NO problems. Its an old trick my dad showed me from back in the day when there were no rocker shaft shims. All you will be out is your time.
Posted By: MRMOPAR622

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 06:07 PM

If he is on this Site in the Race forums his engine/car means more to him than just a Daily driver and although it may never hit the Track I am sure he wants his "Pride & Joy" to be right.Adjustable Rocker arms is the only way to make it 100%right.
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/12/14 06:30 PM

Quote:

If he is on this Site in the Race forums his engine/car means more to him than just a Daily driver and although it may never hit the Track I am sure he wants his "Pride & Joy" to be right.Adjustable Rocker arms is the only way to make it 100%right.




You are wrong sir(read above post`s).............. That would be a horrible waste of money to know EXACTLY where each and every valve is lashed and to have the ability to tighten or loosen to your liking. Plus it sucks to put a nice new roller rocker(another waste of money)w/perfect geometry and less guide wear..............I mean why would anyone want to "step up" into the 20th century when you can guess and wonder................
Posted By: pgccp

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/13/14 03:02 AM

I want to thank everybody for the info. I jump the gun on this
I finally got back to the engine, I was going to try the paper-
clip and I notice that the cups are not into the body the intake is
not on the engine yet so I rotated engine again and re-check the
valves they are not to deep, adjustment seems good so everything
should be good. Thanks again for all the help to everybody. Bob
Posted By: Cab_Burge

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/13/14 04:58 AM

Quote:

I want to thank everybody for the info. I jump the gun on this
I finally got back to the engine, I was going to try the paper-
clip and I notice that the cups are not into the body the intake is
not on the engine yet so I rotated engine again and re-check the
valves they are not to deep, adjustment seems good so everything
should be good. Thanks again for all the help to everybody. Bob


Do you know the name "Mr Murphy"? As in Murphy law You've met him now

Posted By: MadMopars

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/13/14 05:57 AM

At least now we can stop and start. .
Posted By: Thumperdart

Re: Rocker Arms to tight? - 02/13/14 07:02 AM

Hopefully everything works out for ya...............
© 2024 Moparts Forums