Moparts

Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable?

Posted By: 340_Dart

Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/28/13 09:25 PM

I thought I saw a car some time ago that had braided flex line from the master cylinder to the proportioning valve on the frame in place of steel lines. Is this safe and Nhra acceptable to do? It seems to me it would be, but you never know. If anyone has done this, pics would be awesome! Thanks - Andy
Posted By: Challenger 1

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/28/13 09:43 PM

Less is better when it comes to braided brake lines. My car would have steel and will give you a better pedal.
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/28/13 09:56 PM

Its acceptable but the more braided you use the spongier
the pedal feels (I ran braided line for the whole
brake system but I dont like it, I will change it over
to steel line)... for as easy as it is to bend up
the steel I would go with the steel
Posted By: 70Cuda383

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/28/13 11:17 PM

I don't know if there is different grades of the braided brake line or not...but my 05 Durango had braided lines from the master cylinder into the ABS module, and the pedal felt fine.

I agree that the more braided you have the spongier the pedal can feel, but I also don't think a few inches will make a huge difference. look at how long the lines are from the frame to the rear axle, and from the frame to the front calipers, what's a few more inches going to do?
Posted By: HEMIFRED

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 12:29 AM

Use the line made for brakes and are lined with teflon
Posted By: beezer

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 01:32 AM

I had steel line going side to side on my dragster but thought the braided line line looked better, so I changed it. Used the braided line meant for brakes with the teflon lining. My hand brake never got hard and you could watch the braided actually expand when the brakes were applied. The steel line went back on the following week.
Posted By: Challenger 1

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 01:34 AM

Quote:

Use the line made for brakes and are lined with teflon




They still flex and can cause soft petal, even short pieces can.
Posted By: Challenger 1

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 01:41 AM

Quote:

I had steel line going side to side on my dragster but thought the braided line line looked better, so I changed it. Used the braided line meant for brakes with the teflon lining. My hand brake never got hard and you could watch the braided actually expand when the brakes were applied. The steel line went back on the following week.




Me too, I experienced the same thing years ago.
Posted By: Bad340fish

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 03:35 AM

I made some -3 lines from my MC to prop valve along time ago. I noticed no difference in pedal really. Its been that way for 8-10 years now.
Posted By: Crizila

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 03:42 AM

Quote:

I thought I saw a car some time ago that had braided flex line from the master cylinder to the proportioning valve on the frame in place of steel lines. Is this safe and Nhra acceptable to do? It seems to me it would be, but you never know. If anyone has done this, pics would be awesome! Thanks - Andy


Hard line ONLY except to unsprung areas ( axle / caliper, etc). The braided part of a braided line does little ( if any ) control of the line expansion under pressure. It's just a protective cover from external abraision.
Posted By: Dragula

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 12:45 PM

I have this on two vehicles from the master down to the prop valve, never had an issue besides getting all the right fittings. I had to do this on my Cuda so I can move the master out the way when I pull the valve cover.
Posted By: Jerry

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 01:23 PM

Quote:

The braided part of a braided line does little ( if any ) control of the line expansion under pressure. It's just a protective cover from external abraision.




this is absolutely false. the braid is an integral reinforcement to the teflon lining. brake lines work at a few thousand psi and teflon itself would not hold up. the braided brake lines are different than the braided fuel lines. the fuel line braid is there for aesthetics and abrasion resistance. the brake line is braid is there for strength. that being said there are various braided hoses manufacturers and having tested most there is a wide difference in quality between them. the braid needs to be flexible but tight on the core and some of the hoses we worked on had double braided layers.

hoses are designed to move when the braid packages are considered they are designed to swell and shorten as well as some amount of twist is acceptable. this is fine when used in a hydraulic system. its not fine when your using it in a brake system with a limited amount of pedal travel and master cylinder piston/stroke volume.

For those that had a the spongy pedal i would surmise that the extra volume added by the hoses was identifying the limit of the master cylinder if you went with a larger bore master the spongyness would go away, again this a guess, and would need to be tested. as with all engineered hydraulic systems it is important to consider the entire system when selecting parts, most racers don't and very few people actually understand hydraulics.
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 03:58 PM

For those that had a the spongy pedal i would surmise that the extra volume added by the hoses was identifying the limit of the master cylinder if you went with a larger bore master the spongyness would go away, again this a guess, and would need to be tested. as with all engineered hydraulic systems it is important to consider the entire system when selecting parts, most racers don't and very few people actually understand hydraulics.




Well your sorta right and wrong... I first had a
larger bore master.... it had a much higher pedal
and firmer BUT it was still spongy... the pedal travel
was way to short so I went with a smaller bore
to get the pedal travel and it did increase the spongy
feeling as well... it works fine but has the spongy
feel that I dont like.... all due to the growth in
the braided line.... it wasnt air in the system either
cause I bled it MANY times trying to get the feeling right..
its still that way but in the spring I will dump
the braided for the steel(my whole system is all braided)
EDIT
I have the exact same system on my Rampage BUT with
steel line for the most of it other than the normal
points that need the flex(2 front wheels and the axle)
and that system is perfect
Posted By: Jerry

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 04:27 PM

Mr P body, i believe your correct, the braided hose you used could have had a less tight braid that allowed alot of expansion of the teflon. its hard to say, thats why i said it was a guess. since you seem to have ruled out the too small master, it may be a matter of finding a better hose supplier.

just and FYI i am a firm believer in steel lines and only to use hose where absolutely necessary for compliance.
Posted By: MR_P_BODY

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 04:40 PM

Quote:

Mr P body, i believe your correct, the braided hose you used could have had a less tight braid that allowed alot of expansion of the teflon. its hard to say, thats why i said it was a guess. since you seem to have ruled out the too small master, it may be a matter of finding a better hose supplier.

just and FYI i am a firm believer in steel lines and only to use hose where absolutely necessary for compliance.




It was suppose to be the best braided brake line out
there BUT with the whole system being braided, even
a small amount of growth over the whole system will
really add up... I did the braided for 2 reasons..
looks and the ease of the installation... I knew
it would have some growth but I didnt think it would
be as noticeable .... WRONG
EDIT
understand its not a lot and works fine but it has
that spongy feel and that I dont like
Posted By: hemicop

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 07:51 PM

I run braided, high-pressure teflon line from my MC to the proportioning valve, no problem. I'd make sure it can handle the brake pressure as conventional, braidedsteel-over-rubber lines and their fittings may be at their limitfor safe, consistent use. They may cost a bit more, but wel worth it....
Posted By: B G Racing

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 08:03 PM

My car has 100% braided SS line with teflon liner good for over 2000+ line pressure,the same used on heavey equipment on 3800 psi hydrulic systems.It has been on for over 15 years and the pedal feel is great.I have used it on may race cars to plumb the lineloc and prop.valves.
Use only the line recommended for the application.
Posted By: Crizila

Re: Braided line for master cyl. to prop valve. Acceptable? - 01/29/13 08:58 PM

Quote:

Quote:

The braided part of a braided line does little ( if any ) control of the line expansion under pressure. It's just a protective cover from external abraision.




this is absolutely false. the braid is an integral reinforcement to the teflon lining. brake lines work at a few thousand psi and teflon itself would not hold up. the braided brake lines are different than the braided fuel lines. the fuel line braid is there for aesthetics and abrasion resistance. the brake line is braid is there for strength. that being said there are various braided hoses manufacturers and having tested most there is a wide difference in quality between them. the braid needs to be flexible but tight on the core and some of the hoses we worked on had double braided layers.

hoses are designed to move when the braid packages are considered they are designed to swell and shorten as well as some amount of twist is acceptable. this is fine when used in a hydraulic system. its not fine when your using it in a brake system with a limited amount of pedal travel and master cylinder piston/stroke volume.

For those that had a the spongy pedal i would surmise that the extra volume added by the hoses was identifying the limit of the master cylinder if you went with a larger bore master the spongyness would go away, again this a guess, and would need to be tested. as with all engineered hydraulic systems it is important to consider the entire system when selecting parts, most racers don't and very few people actually understand hydraulics.


You are absolutely right. I ment to refer to the steel outer jacket ( abraision ) not the braided layer just outside the teflon liner. That being said, Braided line, not matter who the manufacturer, will expand under pressure. The more of it you use, the more pressure loss will occur when peddle pressure remains constant. Sure, you can overcome the loss by adding more peddle pressure, but you will lose some feel and end up with a spongier feeling peddle. Adding more fluid by going to a bigger master bore sure as hell isn't the answer. Other drawbacks include $$$ and about twice the diameter of steel line - gee, I wonder why?
© 2024 Moparts Forums