Thanks Rob! By the way, it's Lea, not Kim.
I wholeheartedly agree to use originals when possible. However, if you have to choose reproductions the quality and fit varies a lot among manufacturers. You can't really say all of one manufacturers parts are better than another's as they all have parts that may fit to your liking.
About 20 years ago while at Year One in the New Product Development Department, another employee and I, tested two different manufacturers door seals on a '69 Charger. We each liked a different manufacturers fit and for different reasons. So, personal taste can come into play as well.
Fast forward to today, as a business owner, we carry multiple brands and can make recommendations, but still have customer's that insist on a particular brand.
Randy